Gutenberg: Consider implementing the block appender in the Post Title input

Created on 27 May 2019  路  3Comments  路  Source: WordPress/gutenberg

Some feedback was reported to me that it's confusing that you can use the "/" inserter in the default placeholder but not the "post title" especially when starting a new post.

[Feature] Inserter [Type] Enhancement

Most helpful comment

This was discussed in today's triage meeting in slack.

While @kjellr's mockups would solve the issue, it feels like the whole thing might be a non-issue until the Title area becomes an actual block. Using the / is a way to add a new block to the specified wherein one is typing, and the Title area isn't meant to respond that way. The outcome could be more confusing than the current behavior.

I opt for no action here until the Title area becomes an actual block in which case it makes much more sense.

All 3 comments

I spent a few minutes mocking this up. I was originally concerned that it'd be weird to be using the super bold text up there, but it actually seems okay to me.

The main potentially confusing bit would be the focus jump from the title to the inserted block. It theoretically makes sense, but it feels just a little weird to have the title revert back to its placeholder state.

鈻讹笍 Figma Prototype


02

03

04

This was discussed in today's triage meeting in slack.

While @kjellr's mockups would solve the issue, it feels like the whole thing might be a non-issue until the Title area becomes an actual block. Using the / is a way to add a new block to the specified wherein one is typing, and the Title area isn't meant to respond that way. The outcome could be more confusing than the current behavior.

I opt for no action here until the Title area becomes an actual block in which case it makes much more sense.

16281 This issue appears to include this one as well. If the title becomes a block then it will support the appender by default. I am closing this in favour of the one mentioned, we'll see how the UX will be handled when the editor will include title as a block.

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

mhenrylucero picture mhenrylucero  路  3Comments

franz-josef-kaiser picture franz-josef-kaiser  路  3Comments

cr101 picture cr101  路  3Comments

maddisondesigns picture maddisondesigns  路  3Comments

aaronjorbin picture aaronjorbin  路  3Comments