Gt-new-horizons-modpack: Remove rotor disassembling from disassembler
What did you try to do, and what did you expect to happen?
Currently, you can disassemble rotor that is close to broken and effectively getting 100% of the material back. If thats the case, whats the point of having durability on the rotors?
What do you suggest instead/what changes do you propose?
Remove disassembling rotor from disassembler. (Yay for more disassembler recipe removal.)
Proposed method of disassembling rotor:
Arc furnacing a so called broken rotor (basically what rotor turns into when they break or gets to 0 durability), will return you around 40%~60% (I don't know the specific number so please discuss on it) of the material cost for the rotor in ingot / nugget form.
noobyaran9
All 16 comments
100% agree. The disassembling and reassembling of rotors completely negates any running cost turbines have. This seems like a loophole that should be fixed. What's the point of having a durability on the rotor otherwise?
observeroftime02
on 31 Aug 2019
the energy cost to disassemble was a bit more then actually crafting one from scratch.. all you safe is the mats. you still have to monitor to ensure it doesnt totally break, and then wait the time to fix it. when i was doing this, many version ago, I too felt is was wrong, until i calculated the energy use.. this is the balance you seek. Because of this, i had fun messing with rarer turbines, as they were repairable.. much like they do in real life.
Canhos
on 10 Sep 2019
the energy cost to disassemble was a bit more then actually crafting one from scratch
Energy is not the problem, the problem here is the material used.
i calculated the energy use
The energy use is just minor compared to what a rotor could possibly generate.
they were repairable
It's not suppose to use itself to repair itself. More material should be used to repair a rotor (If that were possible).
noobyaran9
on 10 Sep 2019
It's not about the energy cost, but the cost of the material. I could make an infinity turbine, and use it forever without ever having to use new materials for it. That's clearly not right.
observeroftime02
on 10 Sep 2019
I think items with durability should remain disassemblable but their lost durability should impose a penalty on the disassembly returns. For example, there could be a multiplier of 1 - ((%used/100) / 5). In such a system a nearly broken rotor would return 80% as many materials as it normally would in a certain disassembler tier, a 50% rotor would return 90% as many materials as normal, a 75% rotor would return 95% as much, and only a pristine new rotor would return 100% as many materials as before.
sthegreat
on 10 Sep 2019
@sthegreat if you code that I am fine with it. I can only disable it.
Dream-Master
on 10 Sep 2019
not working for me
Dream-Master
on 29 Oct 2019
You have to use the rotor in a turbine first, for it to loose some durability. Then, and only then, can you disassemble it.
observeroftime02
on 29 Oct 2019
ok i need someone with cosing knowledge to disable reverse recipes for turbines.
Dream-Master
on 29 Oct 2019
Might have an idea how and where to do that. Not sure if it will mess anything up. I'll look into it when I get a free moment over the weekend.
observeroftime02
on 29 Oct 2019
sure
Dream-Master
on 29 Oct 2019
Done deal.
observeroftime01
on 30 Oct 2019
@observeroftime02 did you test it?
Dream-Master
on 30 Oct 2019
ok you did. sorry not read the text first
Dream-Master
on 30 Oct 2019
We really need to do a turbine rebalance end to end. :D
richardhendricks
on 30 Oct 2019
sure go for it :) @richardhendricks
Dream-Master
on 30 Oct 2019
Related issues
Proha5
路
3Comments
chochem
路
3Comments
Bluebine
路
3Comments
Prewf
路
3Comments
KaneHart
路
3Comments
Most helpful comment
I think items with durability should remain disassemblable but their lost durability should impose a penalty on the disassembly returns. For example, there could be a multiplier of 1 - ((%used/100) / 5). In such a system a nearly broken rotor would return 80% as many materials as it normally would in a certain disassembler tier, a 50% rotor would return 90% as many materials as normal, a 75% rotor would return 95% as much, and only a pristine new rotor would return 100% as many materials as before.