Gitmoji: :heart: gitmoji for community-related changes

Created on 26 Jun 2020  ยท  13Comments  ยท  Source: carloscuesta/gitmoji

Hello @carloscuesta :sunglasses:!

  • Emoji: :heart:
  • Code: :heart:
  • Description: community-related changes

Inspired by https://github.com/carloscuesta/gitmoji/issues/336#issuecomment-541394183 and https://github.com/carloscuesta/gitmoji/issues/336#issuecomment-640920608.

emoji

Most helpful comment

The meaning of :heart:(community-related) is a scope and does not describe an action. That's why it is problematic to add it as a gitmoji.
If we look at the current list, all gitmojis that are still here describe an action (sometime with a scope); but the action in the repository must be provided (fix โ™ป๏ธ , improving ๐Ÿ” , even mocking ๐Ÿคก ).
And comunity-related changes are somehow covered by ๐Ÿ“, ๐Ÿ‘ฅ. Yet it does not seems perfect so.

Can you @KaKi87 provide some commit messages where โค๏ธ should be used instead of the current gitmojis ! It will helps ๐Ÿ˜„

All 13 comments

What is a community related change ? I think the concept for adding this is not clear

This would include backers/funding/etc. but also credits/contributors/collaborators/etc., annoucements, general communication between devs and end users, and maybe a lot of other things.

@KaKi87 is it really related to a git commit? ๐Ÿค”

What do you mean ?

Do you write commits like adding collaborators on your projects? :thinking:

I mean showing the list of top collaborators in the README, people do that.

Is it not to specific and already covered by ๐Ÿ“?

Well, I don't know, @grissius and @vhoyer said they used it and I just wanted to formalize it and expand it, that's all.

The meaning of :heart:(community-related) is a scope and does not describe an action. That's why it is problematic to add it as a gitmoji.
If we look at the current list, all gitmojis that are still here describe an action (sometime with a scope); but the action in the repository must be provided (fix โ™ป๏ธ , improving ๐Ÿ” , even mocking ๐Ÿคก ).
And comunity-related changes are somehow covered by ๐Ÿ“, ๐Ÿ‘ฅ. Yet it does not seems perfect so.

Can you @KaKi87 provide some commit messages where โค๏ธ should be used instead of the current gitmojis ! It will helps ๐Ÿ˜„

Well, the action is _communicating_. With a project's community.
Hey @grissius & @vhoyer why aren't you there to support your idea ? ^^

I don't think I said I use it because I think I never have used it. I don't really care, but at least it makes more sense to go for more general โค๏ธ then to have a single purpose ๐Ÿ‘ฅ.

If it helps the discussion, here are some examples:

  • Changing contributors
  • Linking to similar projects
  • Adding a demo
  • Code of conduct
  • Issue / PR templates
  • Adding those files that you'd only see in a OSS like FUNDING.md and/or CONTRIBUTING.md

Hi everyone! ๐Ÿ‘‹
Is this issue still open? May I work on it?

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

kevin-dedaniya-rcrm picture kevin-dedaniya-rcrm  ยท  11Comments

joaomoreno picture joaomoreno  ยท  14Comments

johannchopin picture johannchopin  ยท  17Comments

johannchopin picture johannchopin  ยท  18Comments

brenorb picture brenorb  ยท  16Comments