Githawk: Reply button on comments

Created on 20 Feb 2018  ·  6Comments  ·  Source: GitHawkApp/GitHawk

Far right (opposite reaction button). Tap and prefill text with @mention text. Maybe long press to mention _and_ quote?


Bug Report Dump (Auto-generated)

Version 1.18.0 (1519059961)
Device: iPhone X (iOS 11.2.2)
TestFlight: true

❔ question 🆕 feature request

Most helpful comment

I am taking this 😊

All 6 comments

I prefer just quoting. If you are responding to someone in an issue, there's a high chance they are subscribed anyway, so they will receive a notification regardless of them being mentioned or not.

@BasThomas The thing I like about the mention though is it provides some context for the discussion.
Maybe we could do something like automatically insert some form of visual representing where the quote came from 😛

See below:

_BasThomas_:

I prefer just quoting.

Fair point. At that point I would prefer to @mention anyway - to provide context as you said. It wouldn't hurt either (you'll get the notification regardless) and making it bold/italic to mimic something feels even weirder. 😛

I am taking this 😊

Adding the reply button on far right of the reaction button is a problem when it comes to the case when a lot of reactions are there. Moreover, when you have an iPhone SE. Too cluttered
simulator screen shot - iphone se - 2018-03-18 at 13 14 04

I have two suggestions regarding this:

  1. Reply is in the action sheet like Edit, Delete, Share.
  2. Swipe from right to left on comment cell to Reply. ❤️

Let me know what do you think @rnystrom

@jdisho let’s go with putting reply (“reply” btw 😉 ) in the action sheet menu. It’d be fun to convert that menu to a context menu anyways where we can add icons.

Sent with GitHawk

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

rnystrom picture rnystrom  ·  3Comments

weyert picture weyert  ·  3Comments

BasThomas picture BasThomas  ·  3Comments

rizwankce picture rizwankce  ·  3Comments

BasThomas picture BasThomas  ·  3Comments