Gala: Show window titles in Multitasking View

Created on 12 May 2020  路  10Comments  路  Source: elementary/gala

Prerequisites

  • [x] I have searched open and closed issues for duplicates.

Feature

Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe.

Recently I had lots of pdf viewers open and they showed similar pdf files. I wanted to choose with SUPER + DOWN (window overview? ) but I couldnt because they look so similar.

Describe the solution you'd like

Show a tooltip with the window's title so I can distinguish them better.
Existing work

Describe alternatives you've considered

On Windows they show the window's title below the picture of the window.
Additional context

In Progress Confirmed Wishlist Needs Design

Most helpful comment

Yeah, I've wondered about exposing the window title somewhere as well. A tooltip could work to keep the UI looking the same, though it's less discoverable than just putting a label in the UI.

All 10 comments

Yeah, I've wondered about exposing the window title somewhere as well. A tooltip could work to keep the UI looking the same, though it's less discoverable than just putting a label in the UI.

I think that this should absolutely be a feature. Without it, I have to regularly resort to guesswork switching windows (many times every day), which is not a great experience. Some arguments both ways on the labeling style for your consideration:

  • I think that a plain label would be more helpful than a tooltip for scanning. That way I don't have to hover my mouse over every candidate window, although it would require some work to make these labels readable. The simple solution would be to give them a solid background, but I'm not sure that's something we want to do.
  • The tooltips don't provide this information at a glance, but if we make them responsive they can be fairly fast. This would be less cluttered, since every window would have to have a label in the other version. If there are a lot of windows on the desktop, that would be a lot of text, and would force each preview to be even smaller. IMO if we implement this version, we should make sure that the tooltips appear instantly, so I'm not waiting for a fraction of a second over each window I want to check. It would also make the labels discoverable, since they'd appear every time someone uses the multitasking view.

FWIW, GNOME uses permanent labels and macOS uses tooltips.

An example when the multitasking view is difficult to use, happening to me very frequently:
image

@Akryum that's me every day :rofl:

I'm putting something together, it is still in a early stage, but I'll open a PR tomorrow so @cassidyjames can make his magic with the design...

tooltips

I think it looks better with bigger text:

Screenshot from 2021-03-03 19 44 29

@JoseExposito I know it鈥檚 early, but I would say that the icon should always overlap the edge of the window. I would also consider only showing the title on hover (recreating a tooltip) because it _should_ be relatively obvious which app is which in the default use case, while a title on hover can help disambiguate when needed without adding a ton of visual noise all the time.

@cassidyjames But then if you have a lot of windows open (4 or more), it's easier to find the window you want with the names always visible instead of checking them one by one.

On Windows 10 for reference:

image

Chrome OS:
image

Just created a PR with more screenshots of how could it look like.

I'm not a big fan of Windows approach, because, depending on your wallpaper, the text could have little or no contrast. I guess that's why Chrome OS is blurring the background.

I think Windows is adding a transparent black overlay on top of the wallpaper

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

cassidyjames picture cassidyjames  路  4Comments

techdev5521 picture techdev5521  路  3Comments

steakscience picture steakscience  路  3Comments

Janiczek picture Janiczek  路  4Comments

brigazvi picture brigazvi  路  3Comments