Edxposed: [BUG] module doesn't load on Android 10 Samsung note 9 /note 10

[DrKetan]

什么情况/What happened?
Module doesn't load. No error but module not working and log shoeing module doesn't load
如无法开机/模块无效等

Xposed模块列表/Xposed Module List

允许截图/Screenshot allowed

Magisk模块列表/Magisk Module List

允许截图/Screenshot allowed

EdXposed及Riru版本/Versions of EdXposed and Riru

EdXposed:4.6.0

Riru:

相关Logcat/Logcat
[CODE]
--------- beginning of head
EdXposed Log
Powered by Log Catcher
QQ chat group 855219808
--------- beginning of system info
Android version: 10
Android sdk: 29
Android build: QP1A.190711.020
Fingerprint: samsung/d2sxx/d2s:10/QP1A.190711.020/N975FXXU1BSL7:user/release-keys
ROM build description: d2sxx-user 10 QP1A.190711.020 N975FXXU1BSL7 release-keys
EdXposed Version: v0.4.6.0_beta(4471) (Yahfa)
Architecture: arm64-v8a
Device: d2s
Manufacture: samsung
Brand: samsung
Product: d2s
--------- beginning of main
--------- beginning of system
12-19 01:18:06.508 5498 5498 I EdXposed: onModuleLoaded: welcome to EdXposed!
12-19 01:18:06.508 5498 5498 I EdXposed: Start to install inline hooks
12-19 01:18:06.508 5498 5498 I EdXposed: Using api level 29
12-19 01:18:06.508 5498 5498 I EdXposed: Start to install Riru hook
12-19 01:18:06.528 5498 5498 I EdXposed: Riru hooks installed
12-19 01:18:06.540 5499 5499 I EdXposed: onModuleLoaded: welcome to EdXposed!
12-19 01:18:06.540 5499 5499 I EdXposed: Start to install inline hooks
12-19 01:18:06.540 5499 5499 I EdXposed: Using api level 29
12-19 01:18:06.540 5499 5499 I EdXposed: Start to install Riru hook
12-19 01:18:06.559 5499 5499 I EdXposed: Riru hooks installed
12-19 01:18:06.561 5498 5498 I EdXposed: ART hooks installed
12-19 01:18:06.561 5498 5498 I EdXposed: system_property_get: dalvik.vm.dex2oat-filter -> quicken
12-19 01:18:06.561 5498 5498 I EdXposed: system_property_get: dalvik.vm.dex2oat-flags -> --inline-max-code-units=0
12-19 01:18:06.586 5499 5499 I EdXposed: ART hooks installed
12-19 01:18:06.587 5499 5499 I EdXposed: system_property_get: dalvik.vm.dex2oat-filter -> quicken
12-19 01:18:06.587 5499 5499 I EdXposed: system_property_get: dalvik.vm.dex2oat-flags -> --inline-max-code-units=0
12-19 01:18:06.702 5498 5498 I EdXposed: using installer com.solohsu.android.edxp.manager
12-19 01:18:06.703 5498 5498 I EdXposed: black/white list mode: false, using whitelist: false
12-19 01:18:06.703 5498 5498 I EdXposed: dynamic modules mode: false
12-19 01:18:06.703 5498 5498 I EdXposed: resources hook: true
12-19 01:18:06.703 5498 5498 I EdXposed: deopt boot image: false
12-19 01:18:06.704 5499 5499 I EdXposed: using installer com.solohsu.android.edxp.manager
12-19 01:18:06.704 5499 5499 I EdXposed: black/white list mode: false, using whitelist: false
12-19 01:18:06.704 5499 5499 I EdXposed: dynamic modules mode: false
12-19 01:18:06.704 5499 5499 I EdXposed: resources hook: true
12-19 01:18:06.704 5499 5499 I EdXposed: deopt boot image: false
12-19 01:18:13.643 5498 5498 E EdXposed-Bridge: Cannot load any modules because /data/user_de/0/com.solohsu.android.edxp.manager/conf/modules.list was not found
12-19 01:18:20.985 5499 5499 E EdXposed-Bridge: Cannot load any modules because /data/user_de/0/com.solohsu.android.edxp.manager/conf/modules.list was not found
--------- beginning of crash

[/Code]
有助于定位问题，必须使用我们的log抓取模块抓取/It can help us to locate issue, must use our logcat module

[DrKetan]

Sorry, just found it requires recommended version of magisk. Tried it and worked like a charm.

[DrKetan]

Hi
Re-opening again
Tested with newer magisk (recommended 20.1) worked on Note9 but It doesn't solve on Note10 (SAR)

[DrKetan]

I can confirm magisk-EdXposed-YAHFA-v0.4.6.0_beta(4477)-release.zip is working with recommended magisk file on Note10 too.

https://ci.appveyor.com/project/Howard20181/edxposed/builds/28789598/artifacts

[amakuramio]

@DrKetan how did u get it working? on s9+ if i flash howards one, i get a bootloop, to download mode
which magisk version did u use? the magisk from solohsu doesnt work, it says not rooted

[usamaiqbal1177]

There are two magisk (normal/canary and custom solohsu magisk) and two EdXposed versions (normal EdXposed found on this elder driver github and canary edxposed found on solohsu github.... Try out different combinations or these 4 and see which one works for u.... In my one phone, normal magisk with normal edxposed works fine, while in other, solohsu magisk with canary edxposed works fine. Try it out yourself.

[MlgmXyysd]

The two EdXposed custom Magisk you said are the same

[amakuramio]

s9+ android 10
patched solohsu magisk 20.1 = no root
patched solohsu magisk 19.3, no boot
custom sepolicy by rikkaapps, bootloop, system unable to rw, need reflash entire rom and reset, or disable magisk
custom sepolicy patched by howard, bootloop, system unable to rw, need reflash entire rom and reset, or disable magisk
normal canary magisk 20.2, root works, edxposed works, no modules
now what

[MlgmXyysd]

@amakuramio well, Magisk 20.2 will support custom sepolicy

[amakuramio]

@MlgmXyysd then how do i get it working i dont wanna downgrade to pie again

[MlgmXyysd]

@amakuramio wait for Magisk 20.2 to stabilize or use official canary Magisk

[amakuramio]

@MlgmXyysd can you give me a link

[amakuramio]

Any other magisk than 20.2 causes magisk manager app to freeze, cant open it, and no root found

[usamaiqbal1177]

Don't use EdXposed installer. Use EdXposed manager. Install manager apk first.
Completely uninstall magisk from uninstaller zip
Download and flash this solohsu magisk (https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases)
And open manager app and navigate to EdXposed canary tab. Download the canary EdXposed from there. It's name should be "magisk-EdXposed-YAHFA-v0.4.6.0_beta(4478)-release.zip" notice the bracket in the name! Use this canary EdXposed with that custom magisk 20.1 and manager apk. Try this and tell

[ianmacd]

@amakuramio wait for Magisk 20.2 to stabilize or use official canary Magisk

I built Magisk myself with commit 12fda2928051601ebc7fac980fae29a80e7979cc, which is the one that adds support for pre-init custom sepolicy patches, and this still doesn't allow EdXposed 0.4.6.0_beta(4481) to load modules.

These latest EdXposed betas are clearly still targeting the mechanism they implemented and proposed in issue 1685 on the Magisk repo and need to be altered to be compliant with the way John has now actually implemented the feature.

[amakuramio]

@ianmacd nothing worked for me so I downgraded to pie again, having to reset all :(
On pie only custom magisk 19.3 works,

[describe19]

Try this:

Fully uninstall whatever magisk you are using with uninstall zip or full uninstall in magisk manager (or reflash rom to remove).

Flash custom solohsu 20.1 build in twrp. (Idk why root wouldn't work, it should work)

In magisk manager install riru core.

Download ElderDriver's edxposed manager. Go to canary tab and download latest canary build (4481 as of writing).

Add to modules in MM and reboot.

If it doesn't work try the ordinary beta edxposed.
Make sure to try all 4 zips:
Sandhook/yahfa of both canary and beta builds.

Hopefully something works for you.

[ianmacd]

Flash custom solohsu 20.1 build in twrp. (Idk why root wouldn't work, it should work)

In magisk manager install riru core.

Download ElderDriver's edxposed manager. Go to canary tab and download latest canary build (4481 as of writing).

Add to modules in MM and reboot.

If it doesn't work try the ordinary beta edxposed.
Make sure to try all 4 zips:
Sandhook/yahfa of both canary and beta builds.

I've tried the betas and canaries of both Yahfa and Sandhook, and all of them have the same SELinux context issue with reading the module list. The common factor is Magisk itself.

John Wu added support for pre-init custom sepolicy patches in commit 12fda2928051601ebc7fac980fae29a80e7979cc on 13th December, but that doesn't work for EdXposed, so John must have implemented it slightly differently to how the EdXposed author intended.

As a last resort, I tried the custom 20.1 build of Magisk provided by solohsu, but that version comes up unrooted on my Note10+ running Android 10.

So, I'm currently out of options for the time being.

[ianmacd]

@ianmacd nothing worked for me so I downgraded to pie again, having to reset all :(
On pie only custom magisk 19.3 works,

On Pie, all betas of 0.4.6.0 caused a bootloop for me with the HEAD of Magisk. On Android 10, they all boot, but none can load the module list.

[describe19]

Strange, I'm on Android Q and managed to get it working fine. To be fair though I'm on an aosp rom not Samsung, so maybe that's the issue.

[ianmacd]

I'm wondering at this point

Strange, I'm on Android Q and managed to get it working fine. To be fair though I'm on an aosp rom not Samsung, so maybe that's the issue.

I found that build 4477 does work for me, but 4481 does not. So long as I use 4477, both Yahfa and Sandhook variants work.

This is using my own bleeding edge build of Magisk, compiled from the head of the master branch.

[yomyself]

I'm wondering at this point

Strange, I'm on Android Q and managed to get it working fine. To be fair though I'm on an aosp rom not Samsung, so maybe that's the issue.

I found that build 4477 does work for me, but 4481 does not. So long as I use 4477, both Yahfa and Sandhook variants work.

This is using my own bleeding edge build of Magisk, compiled from the head of the master branch.

I have the same issue, only 4477 works with Q but I use official Magisk release

[describe19]

I am using solohsu's latest 20.1 build + magisk-EdXposed-SandHook-v0.4.6.3_beta.Justins.Fork.-release.zip

from here (to avoid snapchat bans): https://github.com/Juxstin/EdXposed-SnapChat-Bypass/releases

[amakuramio]

Can the OP try no custom magisk version plus official 20.2 canary?

[amakuramio]

I'm wondering at this point

Strange, I'm on Android Q and managed to get it working fine. To be fair though I'm on an aosp rom not Samsung, so maybe that's the issue.

I found that build 4477 does work for me, but 4481 does not. So long as I use 4477, both Yahfa and Sandhook variants work.

This is using my own bleeding edge build of Magisk, compiled from the head of the master branch.

Can you share the magisk you compiled?

[amakuramio]

Seems like this solution works https://github.com/Juxstin/EdXposed-SnapChat-Bypass/issues/9
Use sand hook justin no custom magisk and standard canary I think, I'm still on pie so cant confirm

[amakuramio]

tried it again, none of those versions work on s9, just boots me to twrp with selinux patched edexposed, same for justins fork

[amakuramio]

on android q aosp: only magisk-EdXposed-SandHook-v0.4.6.3_beta.Justins.Fork.-release.zip + canary 20.2 work normally

[MlgmXyysd]

@MlgmXyysd can you give me a link

Update channel:

https://raw.githubusercontent.com/topjohnwu/magisk_files/canary/debug.json

Note Canary Magisk is not recommended to use

[deluxor]

@DrKetan working like a charm with your ROM on my Note10+

[alroy214]

Does it work with any modules that attach to system process? I.e. Xposed edge, Greenify and so?
I think there is a problem here...

[ianmacd]

Does it work with any modules that attach to system process? I.e. Xposed edge, Greenify and so?
I think there is a problem here...

I think you're right. Greenify isn't working here (in Boost mode).

[alroy214]

Does it work with any modules that attach to system process? I.e. Xposed edge, Greenify and so?
I think there is a problem here...

I think you're right. Greenify isn't working here (in Boost mode).

Should we open a new issue? I don't think it's a pair app error and it's an exposed issue that's going on with those apps (in Samsung Android 10)

[MlgmXyysd]

@ianmacd ask Greenify author?

[MlgmXyysd]

@ianmacd Greenify test passed i think you should provide log...

http://t.me/code_of_meowcat

[alroy214]

@ianmacd ask Greenify author?

It's also in Xposed Edge and in the system process in GravityBox, I don't think it's a pair app issue.
I think something is wrong with system hooking in EdXposed itself.

[alroy214]

@MlgmXyysd what EdXposed version are you using?

[MlgmXyysd]

@alroy214 legacy, it can always be used

[alroy214]

Does it work with any modules that attach to system process? I.e. Xposed edge, Greenify and so?
I think there is a problem here...

I think you're right. Greenify isn't working here (in Boost mode).

Are you on Samsung Android 10?
I think this problem only effects One UI 2.0 users

[ianmacd]

Are you on Samsung Android 10?
I think this problem only effects One UI 2.0 users

Yes, Android 10 on a Note10+. Build 4477 of Sandhook. The latest build, 4481, doesn't work at all for me.

[alroy214]

Are you on Samsung Android 10?
I think this problem only effects One UI 2.0 users

Yes, Android 10 on a Note10+. Build 4477 of Sandhook. The latest build, 4481, doesn't work at all for me.

Think we should open a new issue on what's happening?

[amakuramio]

Probably a security thing strongly resisting permissive
On s9 series any patched selinux exposed makes data read only then boot to twrp
And only 20.2 will root the device

[alroy214]

Probably a security thing strongly resisting permissive
On s9 series any patched selinux exposed makes data read only then boot to twrp
And only 20.2 will root the device

You can root the device but a lot of modules won't work, and it's also in the S10 and Notes

[MlgmXyysd]

@alroy214 sure

[amakuramio]

tried new 20.2 canary with selinux patch:
4481 sandhook: not working (modules.list)
justins build: not working
justins non magisk build: straight to twrp
howards custom build: straight to twrp
4477 beta sandhook: not working

[describe19]

edxposed-4481-y-sp.zip
Try this with latest canary. Works fine for me.

[amakuramio]

edxposed-4481-y-sp.zip
Try this with latest canary. Works fine for me.

Boots normally, but not working, modules list not found

[MlgmXyysd]

@amakuramio Magisk Canary 20.2?
Check channel for more infonation: http://t.me/edxposed

[amakuramio]

@amakuramio Magisk Canary 20.2?
Check channel for more infonation: http://t.me/edxposed

Yes the latest magisk, doesn't work

[MlgmXyysd]

@amakuramio Samsung OneUI 2.0 Android 10?

[amakuramio]

It works now with latest canary, need to compile yourself.https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposed/issues/379 there is a zip file precompiled. but many apps won't load, many crashes.

[MlgmXyysd]

@amakuramio samsung oem known issues, not this

[THEBOSS619]

So... any known method for having Edxposed for Note 9 Android 10? please let me know :) already on Magisk 20.2

[amakuramio]

So... any known method for having Edxposed for Note 9 Android 10? please let me know :) already on Magisk 20.2

20.3 plus latest edxposed from the app, use canary
Just many modules won't work, Samsung their system is always different, so if you can find an AOSP rom go for it

[MlgmXyysd]

Known Riru issue: https://github.com/RikkaApps/Riru/issues/69 https://github.com/RikkaApps/Riru/issues/73 https://github.com/RikkaApps/Riru/issues/75