Edxposed: [BUG] Safety net is tripped now!

[JReverse]

Safety net is tripped now!

[VarunS2002]

Deactivating all modules is passing safetynet
Activating any module breaks it

[VarunS2002]

I'm using 0.4.5.1
What about you?

[wilsonhlacerda]

Yeah! Same bug here (but I've found workaround!)

Here:
Lineage OS 16 (Android 9)
Newest Official Magisk Canary:
20.2 (20102)
Manager 7.4.1 (255)
Manager Hidden
Newest EdXposed Manager v4.5.1
Newest Riru v19.5
Newest UNOFFICIAL EdXposed v0.4.6.0 beta (4471) SandHook (by Dark_Eyes_ at XDA Forum, to run with official Magisk)
Google Play Store v17.3.16

Lots of modules, including system wide XprivacyLua, Xposed Edge Pro,.....

SafetyNet completely broken in Magisk check. Both CTS and BasicIntegrity fail.

WORKAROUND: after turn on EdXposed Manager Black List feature and turn it on for Play Store, Play Services and Google Framework, SafetyNet becomes all green again! :) Try it!

Hope a fix. Thanks.

[VarunS2002]

Thank you so much dude the workaround worked
I tested it on the Latest Stable of Magisk and 0.4.5.1 Sandhook

[joxon]

Yeah! Same bug here (but I've found workaround!)

Here:
Lineage OS 16 (Android 9)
Newest Official Magisk Canary:
20.2 (20102)
Manager 7.4.1 (255)
Manager Hidden
Newest EdXposed Manager v4.5.1
Newest Riru v19.5
Newest UNOFFICIAL EdXposed v0.4.6.0 beta (4471) SandHook (by Dark_Eyes_ at XDA Forum, to run with official Magisk)
Google Play Store v17.3.16

Lots of modules, including system wide XprivacyLua, Xposed Edge Pro,.....

SafetyNet completely broken in Magisk check. Both CTS and BasicIntegrity fail.

WORKAROUND: after turn on EdXposed Manager Black List feature and turn it on for Play Store, Play Services and Google Framework, SafetyNet becomes all green again! :) Try it!

Hope a fix. Thanks.

Oneplus 7 Pro
AOSiP-9.0-Official-guacamole-20190913
Magisk Canary 20.2 (20102)
Magisk Manager 7.4.1 (255) Hidden
EdXposed Manager v4.5.1
Riru - Core v19.5
Riru - EdXposed v0.4.6.0 SandHook
Google Play Store 17.3.16
Google Play Services 19.5.30

Thank you for your solution but it doesn't work though. Am I missing something? I opened EdXposed Manager then ->Application List -> toggle on "Google Play Store", "Google Play Services" (I have not found any "Google framework" though).

Update: open EdXposed Manager -> Settings -> toggle on "App List Mode" -> Application List -> toggle on "Google Play Store", "Google Play Services" -> reboot -> safetynet passed. Yay!

[blackcatdev]

Unfortunately I had to check also "App List Mode" in Exposed Manager options to pass SafetyNet.

[MlgmXyysd]

Yeah! Same bug here (but I've found workaround!)
Here:
Lineage OS 16 (Android 9)
Newest Official Magisk Canary:
20.2 (20102)
Manager 7.4.1 (255)
Manager Hidden
Newest EdXposed Manager v4.5.1
Newest Riru v19.5
Newest UNOFFICIAL EdXposed v0.4.6.0 beta (4471) SandHook (by Dark_Eyes_ at XDA Forum, to run with official Magisk)
Google Play Store v17.3.16
Lots of modules, including system wide XprivacyLua, Xposed Edge Pro,.....
SafetyNet completely broken in Magisk check. Both CTS and BasicIntegrity fail.
WORKAROUND: after turn on EdXposed Manager Black List feature and turn it on for Play Store, Play Services and Google Framework, SafetyNet becomes all green again! :) Try it!
Hope a fix. Thanks.

Oneplus 7 Pro
AOSiP-9.0-Official-guacamole-20190913
Magisk Canary 20.2 (20102)
Magisk Manager 7.4.1 (255) Hidden
EdXposed Manager v4.5.1
Riru - Core v19.5
Riru - EdXposed v0.4.6.0 SandHook
Google Play Store 17.3.16
Google Play Services 19.5.30

Thank you for your solution but it doesn't work though. Am I missing something? I opened EdXposed Manager then ->Application List -> toggle on "Google Play Store", "Google Play Services" (I have not found any "Google framework" though).

Update: open EdXposed Manager -> Settings -> toggle on "App List Mode" -> Application List -> toggle on "Google Play Store", "Google Play Services" -> reboot -> safetynet passed. Yay!

oh...only pass basicIntegrity on my phone...

[blackcatdev]

Yeah! Same bug here (but I've found workaround!)
Here:
Lineage OS 16 (Android 9)
Newest Official Magisk Canary:
20.2 (20102)
Manager 7.4.1 (255)
Manager Hidden
Newest EdXposed Manager v4.5.1
Newest Riru v19.5
Newest UNOFFICIAL EdXposed v0.4.6.0 beta (4471) SandHook (by Dark_Eyes_ at XDA Forum, to run with official Magisk)
Google Play Store v17.3.16
Lots of modules, including system wide XprivacyLua, Xposed Edge Pro,.....
SafetyNet completely broken in Magisk check. Both CTS and BasicIntegrity fail.
WORKAROUND: after turn on EdXposed Manager Black List feature and turn it on for Play Store, Play Services and Google Framework, SafetyNet becomes all green again! :) Try it!
Hope a fix. Thanks.

Oneplus 7 Pro
AOSiP-9.0-Official-guacamole-20190913
Magisk Canary 20.2 (20102)
Magisk Manager 7.4.1 (255) Hidden
EdXposed Manager v4.5.1
Riru - Core v19.5
Riru - EdXposed v0.4.6.0 SandHook
Google Play Store 17.3.16
Google Play Services 19.5.30
Thank you for your solution but it doesn't work though. Am I missing something? I opened EdXposed Manager then ->Application List -> toggle on "Google Play Store", "Google Play Services" (I have not found any "Google framework" though).
Update: open EdXposed Manager -> Settings -> toggle on "App List Mode" -> Application List -> toggle on "Google Play Store", "Google Play Services" -> reboot -> safetynet passed. Yay!

oh...only pass basicIntegrity on my phone...

Have you tried SafetyPatch or MagiskHide Props Config module?

[cscomic]

Same problem here, after Google play service auto-update last Sunday. It will come ok when I only disable edXposed.

Sony Xperia XZ1
Android 8.0
Magisk 20.1
Riru 19.5
Riru - edXposed 0.4.5.1

solosu's Magisk will cause boot loop, so I haven't test 0.4.6 yet

[kgr17]

WORKAROUND: after turn on EdXposed Manager Black List feature and turn it on for Play Store, Play Services and Google Framework, SafetyNet becomes all green again! :) Try it!

Can confirm it works! Thanks!

[tupac55]

Can confirm this bug and also the working workaround.. but the workaround make sudohide not working anymore :(

Patched magisk with the latest yahfa 4471
Xiaomi Mi9T miui 9.10.24 China beta / Android 10

[wilsonhlacerda]

Can confirm this bug and also the working workaround.. but the workaround make sudohide not working anymore :(

Patched magisk with the latest yahfa 4471
Xiaomi Mi9T miui 9.10.24 China beta / Android 10

Sudohide stops completely? Or just don't hide apps to Play Store (and Google Services, Framework) anymore?

Probably it is failing only to hide app updates on Play Store, isn't it? To hide other generic app A from B I believe it should work, although I haven't tested it.

[tupac55]

Can confirm this bug and also the working workaround.. but the workaround make sudohide not working anymore :(
Patched magisk with the latest yahfa 4471
Xiaomi Mi9T miui 9.10.24 China beta / Android 10

Sudohide stops completely? Or just don't hide apps to Play Store (and Google Services, Framework) anymore?

Probably it is failing only to hide app updates on Play Store, isn't it? To hide other generic app A from B I believe it should work, although I haven't tested it.

It fails to hide..., if I don't enable Googe play store on the app list to make sudohide working, safety net become false after a while (it first says true)

[Senliast]

Same problem, SafetyNet now detects EdXposed.
The workaround is working, but it would be nice if a permanent solution would be found in the next time)

[SteveYoungs]

The workaround works in that Magisk Manager will report safetynet passes. The workaround doesn't work in that Google Pay won't work.

Disabling the EdXposed Magisk module is the only way I've found that'll let me use Google Pay.

[OmarNamis]

@wilsonhlacerda I can confirm this.

[ghost]

The workaround is a hit and miss. Sometimes it passes, sometimes it fails a few seconds later. A permanent solution is needed.

[sipe]

Update: open EdXposed Manager -> Settings -> toggle on "App List Mode" -> Application List -> toggle on "Google Play Store", "Google Play Services" -> reboot -> safetynet passed. Yay!

Hello all,

HTC U11
Stock Android 9 3.23.709.6
Magisk 20.2 (20100)
Manager 7.4.0 (253)
EdXposed Manager v4.5.1 4463 YAHFA
Riru v19.5
Google Play Store v17.3.16
Google Play Services v19.5.30

Confirmed GPay working workaround, Magisk safetynet also passes, selected Google Play services and Google Services Framework.

Thank you.

[ghost]

Ok, the workaround works when EdXposed Manager is open in the background. I tried deoptimizing battery for the Manager, and now SafetyNet works.

EDIT: Never mind. Still hit and miss.

[srccrow]

We can still use sudohide, so far I added to blacklist only the services and framework; I also tested with a old version of SandHook with success, I can confirm that "App List Mode" enabled seems essential in order to success.

[shmykelsa]

For me SafetyNet passing is quite interesting. After enabling EdXposed + modules, upon every reboot the first check of Safetynet within Magisk Manager will fail in both profiles. Second check will report all trues. Checking with other apps will report always true. But then leaving the device for some time will result in Magisk reporting safetynet false again. I assume that Magisk Manager is bugged in SafetyNet check?

EDIT: No, it's not just Magisk. Even with other Safetynet checkers, randomly Safetynet fails, but then the moment very after it passes fine.

[saqie1393]

open EdXposed Manager -> Settings -> toggle on "App List Mode" ->

i am not find these setting ?

[kgr17]

open EdXposed Manager -> Settings -> toggle on "App List Mode" ->

i am not find these setting ?

I use the Edxposed Installer app and it's in menu> edxp settings> black list (toggle). Then reboot and go to menu> black list

[p1r473]

Workaround is not working for me. Can someone post clearer instructions?

[DU1R]

I did only the application list workaround and it's working for version "0.4.5.1_beta(4463) (YAHFA)" on my OP6T running stock 9.0.17 and Magisk Stable 20.1.

Here are more detailed instructions:
Open EdXposed Manager
Tap the menu icon on top left
Tap settings.
Scroll down to the bottom and toggle "App List Mode"
Go back to main screen (back button or arrow at top left)
Tap menu icon again
Tap Application List
Tap the toggle for "Google Play Services"
Tap the toggle for "Google Play Store"
Reboot phone
Wait 1-2 minutes after reboot and device will pass.

I literally just did this on my phone so I can't say yet as to whether it works intermittently or not, but I can confirm it passes SafetyNet check in Magisk Manager and Pokemon GO now opens where before it wasn't.

[zioukovsky]

safetynet works but snapfreedom do nothing :/ lets see how long I will wait for ban :D

[Senliast]

safetynet works but snapfreedom do nothing :/ lets see how long I will wait for ban :D

Are you sure that you do not have SC alpha?
Deselect and select snapfreedom in EdXposed manager, reboot device.

P.S. Snapchat doesn't ban for failing SafetyNet

[hoistedPetard]

Has anyone tried the Hidden Core module in EdXposed? It is passing SafetyNet for me without any blacklisting or switching modes, just install and reboot.

For posterity, I am running EdXposed YAHFA 0.4.5.1. EdXposed Manager 4.5.1 under Magisk v20.1 / Android Pie.

https://ibb.co/xLBxDDV
https://ibb.co/F6y1hcH

[joxon]

Has anyone tried the Hidden Core module in EdXposed? It is passing SafetyNet for me without any blacklisting or switching modes, just install and reboot.

For posterity, I am running EdXposed YAHFA 0.4.5.1. EdXposed Manager 4.5.1 under Magisk v20.1 / Android Pie.

https://ibb.co/xLBxDDV
https://ibb.co/F6y1hcH

Confirmed working.
Disabled AppList Mode in EdXposed Manager and enabled HiddenCore Module. Rebooted and passed SafetyNet in Magisk Manager.

However, Pokemon go won't be able to start up, throwing out the "unable to authenticate" error.

[tupac55]

Has anyone tried the Hidden Core module in EdXposed? It is passing SafetyNet for me without any blacklisting or switching modes, just install and reboot.

For posterity, I am running EdXposed YAHFA 0.4.5.1. EdXposed Manager 4.5.1 under Magisk v20.1 / Android Pie.

https://ibb.co/xLBxDDV
https://ibb.co/F6y1hcH

This module is making chrome app crashing again and again :(

[wrongway213]

Has anyone tried the Hidden Core module in EdXposed? It is passing SafetyNet for me without any blacklisting or switching modes, just install and reboot.
For posterity, I am running EdXposed YAHFA 0.4.5.1. EdXposed Manager 4.5.1 under Magisk v20.1 / Android Pie.
https://ibb.co/xLBxDDV
https://ibb.co/F6y1hcH

This module is making chrome app crashing again and again :(

Yeah, I can confirm this makes Chrome crash without fail unless I roll back to version 74. It works with Hidden Core Module on that version.

[hoistedPetard]

I did read the few writeups on XDA about it and agree caution is advisable, but it looks like it is not malicious and that it at least used to work as advertised.

If it is killing Chrome, that will be a deal breaker for a lot of people. Oh well, something will happen soon, it always does. :)

[p1r473]

I did only the application list workaround and it's working for version "0.4.5.1_beta(4463) (YAHFA)" on my OP6T running stock 9.0.17 and Magisk Stable 20.1.

Here are more detailed instructions:
Open EdXposed Manager
Tap the menu icon on top left
Tap settings.
Scroll down to the bottom and toggle "App List Mode"
Go back to main screen (back button or arrow at top left)
Tap menu icon again
Tap Application List
Tap the toggle for "Google Play Services"
Tap the toggle for "Google Play Store"
Reboot phone
Wait 1-2 minutes after reboot and device will pass.

I literally just did this on my phone so I can't say yet as to whether it works intermittently or not, but I can confirm it passes SafetyNet check in Magisk Manager and Pokemon GO now opens where before it wasn't.

Followed this and it did not work for me. Still failing Safetynet.

[robbyoconnor]

It works for me! Ensure you blacklist Pokemon Go in both Magisk Hide and EdXposed Manager.

[robbyoconnor]

So this is really weird, it will pass and then start failing on me randomly and then pass after I kill off the gms data dir and reboot

[robbyoconnor]

@ffsec -- It checked all of the packages within Google Play Services.

[ecompton59]

and add magisk mod adb and fastboot Android ndk it stops random reboots and helps with edxposed

[tupac55]

I found an other workaround that works better than this inconsistent " app list mode " workaround...

My workaround is simply go to TWRP and wipe cache and dalvik .. safety net is true and stay true without inconsistency until next reboot .. so every reboot have to wipe cache and dalvik to pass safety net until an other better workaround or a permanent fix is made

[robbyoconnor]

Works for me on Android 10 by just blacklisting via MagiskHide and EdXposed Manager. Also on A/B devices, there is no cache partition.

[ai212983]

Does NOT works for me. Android 10, Riru Core 19.5, EdXposed 0.4.6.0_beta (YAHFA) with selinux fix (probably that fix itself is a problem)

[robbyoconnor]

Working fine for me. See this:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/magisk-google-pay-gms-17-1-22-pie-t3929950

Don't change it -- just setting the db read-only to the user, group and
inaccessible entirely to the world (440) worked for me.

On 11/13/19 1:56 PM, Dimitri Fedorov wrote:
>

Does NOT works for me. Android 10, Riru Core 19.5, EdXposed
0.4.6.0_beta (YAHFA) with selinux fix

—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposed/issues/386?email_source=notifications&email_token=AAAFUMEAVDKK53U73SQJZ43QTREVXA5CNFSM4JJOWDLKYY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOED7HZQI#issuecomment-553548993,
or unsubscribe
https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAAFUMBL5BVYG232H4WH7ETQTREVXANCNFSM4JJOWDLA.

[Dreamerrrr]

A few days ago I tried most of the fixes listed here and would swap between tripping and passing SafetyNet.

Today, I've done two things differently, and I haven't tripped SafetyNet yet with EdXposed + GravityBox + MinMinGuard + XPrivacyLua.

I updated this Magisk module (GPay-SQLite-Fix) and EdXposed Manager to 4.5.2.

I have Google Play Services, Google Play Store, Google Services Framework, and Carrier Services marked on EdXposed Black List and I do NOT have App List Mode enabled anymore.

I'll be watching my phone over the next few days to see if anything breaks.

EDIT: Over a week in. Still passing SafetyNet. Still certified in Play Store. Still have the ability to download apps like Netflix in Play Store. I forgot to mention I am also using the "SafetyPatch" Magisk module, but I was using that before I updated the GPay-SQLite-Fix module and would fail from time to time. Also using a custom kernel (ElementalX).

[thippeswamydc]

A few days ago I tried most of the fixes listed here and would swap between tripping and passing SafetyNet.

Today, I've done two things differently, and I haven't tripped SafetyNet yet with EdXposed + GravityBox + MinMinGuard + XPrivacyLua.

I updated this Magisk module (GPay-SQLite-Fix) and EdXposed Manager to 4.5.2.

I have Google Play Services, Google Play Store, Google Services Framework, and Carrier Services marked on EdXposed Black List and I do NOT have App List Mode enabled anymore.

I'll be watching my phone over the next few days to see if anything breaks.

Hi, Thank you, I tried all what u said and it worked for me.

[gautamajay52]

I have found a module in edxposed named "HiddenCore Module'', this helped me to pass safety net without any workaround.

Try this.... If is it passing for you or not.

[tupac55]

I have found a module in edxposed named "HiddenCore Module'', this helped me to pass safety net without any workaround.

Try this.... If is it passing for you or not.

This module as said before only trick and doesn't fully pass the safety net ( you can't download Netflix or use gpay with it ) more of that it makes chrome browser crash

[gautamajay52]

I have found a module in edxposed named "HiddenCore Module'', this helped me to pass safety net without any workaround.
Try this.... If is it passing for you or not.

This module as said before only trick and doesn't fully pass the safety net ( you can't download Netflix or use gpay with it ) more of that it makes chrome browser crash

No bro...it is all working
Right now I am using this module along with GPay, Chrome, And other 4 different banking apps too. Sorry to say that I am not using netflix.
But I am going to install, and tell u the result.

I have also flashed a magisk module - safety patch as before this bug this module is doing its job to pass the safety net. Now I have to use both for passing safety net.

[cscomic]

No any other module, just follow steps below I pass the safetynet:

1. add "Google Play Service" , "Google Play Store", "Google Services Framework" into blacklist in edXposed Manager App.
2. make sure the "Black/White list" option is on in "edXp Settings".
3. reboot, then the "Basic Integrity" pass, and google pay, netflix, mhxr, mario run… can run
4. for addition, get Magisk module "safety patch" can make "ctsProfile" pass , when Magisk's version is 18+

[hoistedPetard]

If anyone needs JUST Netflix, the Magisk module Libemcrypto Disable works fine with no other modules or blacklisting. This will not work for Pay though.

HiddenCore is hit and miss, it works about as well as sudohide, which is to say that it is slightly more effective than a rabbits foot.

[piyoosh-singh]

SafetyNet Failed

Device : raphelin
Rom : MIUI 11, Android Q
Using Magisk 20.1
Edxposed : 4.5.2

added "Google Play Service" , "Google Play Store", "Google Services Framework" into blacklist in edXposed Manager App.

Tried various alpha & canary built of sandhook & YAHFA. Still no success.
Finally i have to remove Edxposed

[ecompton59]

probably running different kernel is reason you're having issue with install smurf works and stop crashing with the adb and fastboot magisk mod it creats a wrapper script to point where adb file is located (magisk and mods are there)

[SriHarshaMande]

Google Pay is some how detecting root

Initially I had edxposed module and saftey net passed and Google pay works fine

Issue started yesterday..
safety net passed.But Google pay not working
I removed all magisk modules but no luck
Any fixes

Device : OnePlus 5t
Stock rom with magisk

[shmykelsa]

Google Pay is some how detecting root

Initially I had edxposed module and saftey net passed and Google pay works fine

Issue started yesterday..
safety net passed.But Google pay not working
I removed all magisk modules but no luck
Any fixes

Device : OnePlus 5t
Stock rom with magisk

Keep in mind that you should also put Google Pay and all Google Play Services in Magisk Hide

[SriHarshaMande]

Google Pay is some how detecting root
Initially I had edxposed module and saftey net passed and Google pay works fine
Issue started yesterday..
safety net passed.But Google pay not working
I removed all magisk modules but no luck
Any fixes
Device : OnePlus 5t
Stock rom with magisk

Keep in mind that you should also put Google Pay and all Google Play Services in Magisk Hide

Sorry for not to mention..
I checked every banking and Google apps in magisk hide
And black listed in edxposed ..

[tgt26]

Google Pay is some how detecting root

Initially I had edxposed module and saftey net passed and Google pay works fine

Issue started yesterday..
safety net passed.But Google pay not working
I removed all magisk modules but no luck
Any fixes

Device : OnePlus 5t
Stock rom with magisk

I can also pass Safety Net but can't use GPay. I used the blacklist/applist method.

[shmykelsa]

Quick example of how Safetynet just randomly fails, but then it's all good a few moments later

[robbyoconnor]

I am definately experiencing this.

On 11/16/19 10:07 AM, Gabriele Rizzo wrote:
>

Screenshot_20191116-160215
https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/9965637/68995185-1d1ae680-088b-11ea-9487-2e9325150ff9.jpg
Screenshot_20191116-160220
https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/9965637/68995186-1d1ae680-088b-11ea-88ab-5ce731822683.jpg

Quick example of how Safetynet just randomly fails, but then it's all
good a few moments later

—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposed/issues/386?email_source=notifications&email_token=AAAFUMHBYW7EDSIUKBNNMWTQUAEC5A5CNFSM4JJOWDLKYY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEEHTP3Q#issuecomment-554645486,
or unsubscribe
https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAAFUMFY7OZBLQCZX646WELQUAEC5ANCNFSM4JJOWDLA.

[GorvGoyl]

many above mentioned tweaks are passing the safety net but somehow Google pay (tez) and some other apps are still detecting the root

[robbyoconnor]

You pass for awhile and then fail

On 11/17/19 5:50 AM, Gourav Goyal wrote:
>

many above mentioned tweaks are passing safety net but somehow Google
pay (tez) is detecting the root

—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposed/issues/386?email_source=notifications&email_token=AAAFUMBJSYPAA4IGDD3MCADQUEOXLA5CNFSM4JJOWDLKYY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEEIJB5I#issuecomment-554733813,
or unsubscribe
https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAAFUMHAKVOAIZRILI5JRQLQUEOXLANCNFSM4JJOWDLA.

[cscomic]

Another device pass safetynet and use Google Pay and buy a APP:

Sony xperia xz1c
Stock Rom Android 9
Magisk 20.1 + dm-verity enabled + kernel hide unlock
Riru 19.5
Riru - edXposed 0.4.5.1
safety patch v3

just open "Black list/White list" option in edxp settings, put "Google Play services", "Google Play store", "Google Service framework", "Google Pay" in black list; last use Magisk hide with Google Pay.

[SriHarshaMande]

many above mentioned tweaks are passing the safety net but somehow Google pay (tez) and some other apps are still detecting the root

Did anyone find the root cause and fixes for this problem

[ecompton59]

i switched from edxposed manager back to just the installer apk used that with black list i have no issue

[robbyoconnor]

And it continues to pass, correct?

On 11/20/19 10:43 AM, Sri Harsha wrote:
>

i switched from edxposed manager back to just the installer apk
used that with black list i have no issue

Thank you,,It worked.

—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposed/issues/386?email_source=notifications&email_token=AAAFUMGUAMI6AQ6JQLOJXSLQUVLIJA5CNFSM4JJOWDLKYY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEESNHII#issuecomment-556061601,
or unsubscribe
https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAAFUMEOZ3F5Q4LXNUM2D73QUVLIJANCNFSM4JJOWDLA.

[ayush7gl]

Yes confirmed. it has been a week or 2, now the SafetyNet doesn't pass anymore. I've to enable App list mode and blacklist google play services, which breaks some modules and hooks but SafetyNet pass on blacklisting google play services. Please fix this issue. I think it's because google updated google play services which detects xposed being installed on the device.

[m4cklove]

Worked like a charm both safetynet worked but I had one issue only the basic was green.. I had to remove safetypatch and magiskhideprop and redo magiskhideprop to get ctsprofile true.. Thanks for this wonderful fix

[ecompton59]

Glad it helped. yes works easy i use substratum and ut dont break it either like it did with manager.ive never used manager just installer. i put fix on xda on OnePlus 7 pro when you update and what you need to do https://forum.xda-developers.com/oneplus-7-pro/how-to/updating-oos-uninstall-overlays-t4006219

[TheProphet2304]

I use a Note 8 with HadesRomPie v11.1(SDK 28 EXYNOS) and PhantomKernel 2.9 for P

Magisk 7.4.1
Magisk zip 20.2
EdxposedManager 5.4.2
Framework 4.6.0 (4478) Sandhook canary
Hide-magisk
In edxposed settings check app-list mode
In black list check carrier services, google play, google services and google framework
REBOOT in TWRP------wipe dalvik cache and cache
Reboot and safetynet & basicIntegrity will pass 100%
I use the note 8 over a week with this settings and still pass safetynet without problems!!!! WITH SANDHOOK!!!!

[robbyoconnor]

Check in 12-24 hrs and report back.
On 11/21/19 7:15 PM, TheProphet2304 wrote:
>

I use a Note 8 with HadesRomPie v11.1(SDK 28 EXYNOS) and PhantomKernel
2.9 for P

Magisk 7.4.1
Magisk zip 20.2
EdxposedManager 5.4.2
Framework 4.6.0 (4478) Sandhook canary
Hide-magisk
In edxposed settings check app-list mode
In black list check carrier services, google play, google services and
google framework
REBOOT in TWRP------wipe dalvik cache and cache
Reboot and safetynet & basicIntegrity will pass 100%
I use the note 8 over a week with this settings and still pass
safetynet without problems!!!! WITH SANDHOOK!!!!
Screenshot_20191122-002847
https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/58054716/69387138-2b229a00-0cc5-11ea-9fcd-68a5f91e052a.jpg
Screenshot_20191122-011353_EdXposed Manager
https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/58054716/69387194-6a50eb00-0cc5-11ea-84cb-0b207e8eb86f.jpg
Screenshot_20191122-011338_EdXposed Manager
https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/58054716/69387202-70df6280-0cc5-11ea-9115-439a0054beda.jpg
Screenshot_20191122-011311_EdXposed Manager
https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/58054716/69387219-7c328e00-0cc5-11ea-8e05-2d8bd1c848e9.jpg

—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposed/issues/386?email_source=notifications&email_token=AAAFUMAZCA2VUBC2CBUZCELQU4QCHA5CNFSM4JJOWDLKYY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEE4C62Y#issuecomment-557330283,
or unsubscribe
https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAAFUMAMY4NCXDBVLKHPD6DQU4QCHANCNFSM4JJOWDLA.

[TheProphet2304]

24 hrs left......and i restarted my note 8 twice (new modules)......and its all passed!!!
Games, Banking apps, Payback, Paypal, Netflix.....etc......ALL WORKS FINE!!!

https://youtu.be/0yMG3NO8cys

[nritech]

24 hrs left......and i restarted my note 8 twice (new modules)......and its all passed!!!
Games, Banking apps, Payback, Paypal, Netflix.....etc......ALL WORKS FINE!!!

https://youtu.be/0yMG3NO8cys

I use a Note 8 with HadesRomPie v11.1(SDK 28 EXYNOS) and PhantomKernel 2.9 for P

Magisk 7.4.1
Magisk zip 20.2
EdxposedManager 5.4.2
Framework 4.6.0 (4478) Sandhook canary
Hide-magisk
In edxposed settings check app-list mode
In black list check carrier services, google play, google services and google framework
REBOOT in TWRP------wipe dalvik cache and cache
Reboot and safetynet & basicIntegrity will pass 100%
I use the note 8 over a week with this settings and still pass safetynet without problems!!!! WITH SANDHOOK!!!!

Well I tried your method on my Redmi note 7 Pro
Upgraded to Magisk 7.4.0
Magisk zip 20.2

Flashed:
Rirucore 19.5
Magisk-EdXposed-SandHook-v0.4.6.0_beta(4478)
Install EdxposedManager 4.5.2

Hide-magisk: in magisk hide all google apps/services
In edxposed settings check app-list mode
In black list check carrier services, google play, google services and google framework in fact I incl. every google service in this list
REBOOTED in TWRP--did wipe dalvik cache and cache

Now phone is still on loading screen since 20mins
Dont know if its due to wipe cache/dalvik.

---

[TheProphet2304]

Then something goes wrong.......
What are you do at last....before you stucked at loading screen?????
Xposed framework or another module????

You dont need to hide ALL google apps!!!!
Maybe you must uninstall edxposed with edxposed uninstallerV3!!! Then you come out from loading screen!!!!

[Senliast]

Can you guys test it without enabling Black list for play store and write did it worked for you or not?

[TheProphet2304]

I have unchecked play store in black list.
Reboot phone.......SAFETYNET FAILED!!!!

[nritech]

Then something goes wrong.......
What are you do at last....before you stucked at loading screen?????
Xposed framework or another module????

You dont need to hide ALL google apps!!!!
Maybe you must uninstall edxposed with edxposed uninstallerV3!!! Then you come out from loading screen!!!!

I caught the culprit.
magisk-EdXposed-SandHook-v0.4.6.0_beta(4478) was the issue.

Deleted this module from twrp and phone booted properly.

Then flashed magisk-EdXposed-SandHook-v0.4.5.1 and rebooted.

Now all seems to work perfectly fine. All tests passing cool!!
But fingers crossed. Need to test for next 2 days to be sure.

I only needed insta module to download instagram stuff. . So far working good.

I also need one important module which can work on Pie and remove the Lockscreen tint/dark shade. Which module can help here?

[nritech]

All is good except Battery drain issue still persists. Can someone explain the relation between installing edxposed and battery drain?

[robbyoconnor]

Works for me now lol

On 11/24/19 12:38 AM, nritech wrote:
>

All is good except Battery drain issue still persists. Can someone
explain the relation between installing edxposed and battery drain?

—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposed/issues/386?email_source=notifications&email_token=AAAFUMAOEYLTOU7UXOMCYE3QVIHNDA5CNFSM4JJOWDLKYY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEFAEH4Y#issuecomment-557859827,
or unsubscribe
https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAAFUMFHCW6A3OMGFNPFKMDQVIHNDANCNFSM4JJOWDLA.

[SriHarshaMande]

Then something goes wrong.......
What are you do at last....before you stucked at loading screen?????
Xposed framework or another module????
You dont need to hide ALL google apps!!!!
Maybe you must uninstall edxposed with edxposed uninstallerV3!!! Then you come out from loading screen!!!!

I caught the culprit.
magisk-EdXposed-SandHook-v0.4.6.0_beta(4478) was the issue.

Deleted this module from twrp and phone booted properly.

Then flashed magisk-EdXposed-SandHook-v0.4.5.1 and rebooted.

Now all seems to work perfectly fine. All tests passing cool!!
But fingers crossed. Need to test for next 2 days to be sure.

I only needed insta module to download instagram stuff. . So far working good.

I also need one important module which can work on Pie and remove the Lockscreen tint/dark shade. Which module can help here?

Can you give me that insta module link or name

[robbyoconnor]

XInsta
On 11/24/19 2:19 AM, Sri Harsha wrote:
>

    Then something goes wrong.......
    What are you do at last....before you stucked at loading
    screen?????
    Xposed framework or another module????
    You dont need to hide ALL google apps!!!!
    Maybe you must uninstall edxposed with edxposed
    uninstallerV3!!! Then you come out from loading screen!!!!

I caught the culprit.
magisk-EdXposed-SandHook-v0.4.6.0_beta(4478) was the issue.

Deleted this module from twrp and phone booted properly.

Then flashed magisk-EdXposed-SandHook-v0.4.5.1 and rebooted.

Now all seems to work perfectly fine. All tests passing cool!!
But fingers crossed. Need to test for next 2 days to be sure.

I only needed insta module to download instagram stuff. . So far
working good.

I also need one important module which can work on Pie and remove
the Lockscreen tint/dark shade. Which module can help here?

Can you give me that insta module link or name

—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposed/issues/386?email_source=notifications&email_token=AAAFUMEIIHUBK6ZD7ANFV5DQVITG5A5CNFSM4JJOWDLKYY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEFAFKJY#issuecomment-557864231,
or unsubscribe
https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAAFUMHIYUKEGAPETFRTQY3QVITG5ANCNFSM4JJOWDLA.

[flostingapplesauce]

What TheProphet2304 suggested is working for me on LineageOS 16 Official. I also have Liboemcrypt Disabler installed.

This is a little off-topic, but it might be helpful to someone.

For people who are meticulously going through Magisk and EdXposed modules to troubleshoot:

https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/tool-magisk-manager-recovery-tool-v1-0-t3866502/amp/

You don't have to install it, just stash the .zip file on your phone storage somewhere, and use it when needed. It is a menu driven Magisk module management tool, a program that runs from TWRP without actually installing. When a Magisk module causes a problem, just run TWRP, "Install" the .zip (it runs on demand in memory, doesn't really install) and you can disable or uninstall any Magisk modules, or put Magisk into Core Only mode. If it is an EdXposed module causing a problem, just temporarily disable the EdXposed module.

It doesn't do anything that you couldn't do from fastboot or adb, but it is usually easier and more convenient to not have to tether to a PC, or muck around in a command line on your phone.

I have nothing to do with this program, it has just saved me a lot of time.

[DC2Brooklyn]

Can I ask, has anyone tried falling back to EdXposed 0.4.4.4? Is this issue just with 0.4.5.1 and 0.4.6.0? I'm having trouble with GPay transactions failing, and with SafetyNet passing, then failing, then passing, even with relevant apps blacklisted. Are there any potential pitfalls to downgrading?

[nritech]

Can someone confirm why my phone is heating after installing edxposed etc?
Also, screen doesnt turn on in one go, have to tap multiple times on display or power button needs to be pressed few times.

[iamthekings5]

Can I ask, has anyone tried falling back to EdXposed 0.4.4.4? Is this issue just with 0.4.5.1 and 0.4.6.0? I'm having trouble with GPay transactions failing, and with SafetyNet passing, then failing, then passing, even with relevant apps blacklisted. Are there any potential pitfalls to downgrading?

Hi! Just to let you know, I tried downgrading to 0.4.4.4 Sandhook and SafetyNet still failed. Tried 0.4.5.1 both Sandhook and the other version, also failed.

Seems only way for now is to blacklist the services / apps.

S10+ on custom rom

[cazkiller]

thx that's work for me

[tupac55]

thx that's work for me

That's not a permanent fix , it will fail after a while and be true just after, it's very random..

[cazkiller]

thx that's work for me

That's not a permanent fix , it will fail after a while and be true just after, it's very random..

wht u mean, i check it but still green

[robbyoconnor]

If it fails, reinstalling Magisk has helped me.

On 11/28/19 11:29 PM, cazkiller wrote:
>

    thx that's work for me

That's not a permanent fix , it will fail after a while and be
true just after, it's very random..

Screenshot_20191129-112249_Magisk_Manager
https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/58269568/69843585-c81f9d00-129a-11ea-92ab-9e3de8a1e89a.png
wht u mean, i check it but still green

—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposed/issues/386?email_source=notifications&email_token=AAAFUMG23YAJRZZ526OQ5KLQWCLCBA5CNFSM4JJOWDLKYY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEFN2XGY#issuecomment-559655835,
or unsubscribe
https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAAFUMF3IPH4DQAV5KV3A5TQWCLCBANCNFSM4JJOWDLA.

[nritech]

When my phone is in pocket mostly its warm irrespective of turning off Double tap to Sleep or Wake.
Whats wrong? This issue is haunting me.
I have even flashed a new rom but after installing magisk its eating my battery like anything.

[nritech]

Right now I've formatted my phone and flashed new rom with all stock apps.

As soon as I install Magisk (no edxposed), the phone is loosing battery when its in pocket and is getting warm due to excessive battery drain. If phone isn't in pocket the battery seems ok and phone also isn't warm.

Double tap to Wake/Sleep is disabled.
No battery draining observed by any apps.

[robbyoconnor]

I have not noticed this. What phone?
On 11/29/19 11:58 AM, nritech wrote:
>

Right now I've formatted my phone and flashed new rom with all stock apps.

As soon as I install Magisk (no edxposed), the phone is loosing
battery when its in pocket and is getting warm due to excessive
battery drain. If phone isn't in pocket the battery seems ok and phone
also isn't warm.

Double tap to Wake/Sleep is disabled.
No battery draining observed by any apps.

—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposed/issues/386?email_source=notifications&email_token=AAAFUMAKPYFPH4FKML4XX63QWFC3NA5CNFSM4JJOWDLKYY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEFPI3ZQ#issuecomment-559844838,
or unsubscribe
https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAAFUMFAK3PZFOUH3D2UZLDQWFC3NANCNFSM4JJOWDLA.

[nritech]

I have not noticed this. What phone?
…
On 11/29/19 11:58 AM, nritech wrote: Right now I've formatted my phone and flashed new rom with all stock apps. As soon as I install Magisk (no edxposed), the phone is loosing battery when its in pocket and is getting warm due to excessive battery drain. If phone isn't in pocket the battery seems ok and phone also isn't warm. Double tap to Wake/Sleep is disabled. No battery draining observed by any apps. — You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#386?email_source=notifications&email_token=AAAFUMAKPYFPH4FKML4XX63QWFC3NA5CNFSM4JJOWDLKYY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEFPI3ZQ#issuecomment-559844838>, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAAFUMFAK3PZFOUH3D2UZLDQWFC3NANCNFSM4JJOWDLA.

Redmi Note 7 Pro

[robbyoconnor]

Then it's likely your ROM -- don't blame Magisk when you haven't ruled
out everything else.
On 11/30/19 7:19 AM, nritech wrote:
>

I have not noticed this. What phone?
… <#>
On 11/29/19 11:58 AM, nritech wrote: Right now I've formatted my
phone and flashed new rom with all stock apps. As soon as I
install Magisk (no edxposed), the phone is loosing battery when
its in pocket and is getting warm due to excessive battery drain.
If phone isn't in pocket the battery seems ok and phone also isn't
warm. Double tap to Wake/Sleep is disabled. No battery draining
observed by any apps. — You are receiving this because you
commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#386
<https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposed/issues/386>?email_source=notifications&email_token=AAAFUMAKPYFPH4FKML4XX63QWFC3NA5CNFSM4JJOWDLKYY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEFPI3ZQ#issuecomment-559844838>,
or unsubscribe
https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAAFUMFAK3PZFOUH3D2UZLDQWFC3NANCNFSM4JJOWDLA.

Redmi Note 7 Pro

—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposed/issues/386?email_source=notifications&email_token=AAAFUMCVPLUQVHEQWWSP2HLQWJK5HA5CNFSM4JJOWDLKYY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEFQEXLI#issuecomment-559958957,
or unsubscribe
https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAAFUMAWI3KBLOTXAI5LY53QWJK5HANCNFSM4JJOWDLA.

[tupac55]

Please come back to the main subject.. edxposed tripping safetynet...

Issues with magisk or not related with safetynet shouldn't be on this thread

[flostingapplesauce]

Please come back to the main subject.. edxposed tripping safetynet...

Issues with magisk or not related with safetynet shouldn't be on this thread

You said what everyone else was thinking. :)

Unfortunately it has been weeks now, and it does not look like EdXposed is likely to have a singular fix that will work for everyone on every device out of the box. It is beginning to look like we will have to work with what we currently have and know. We just need to find the commonalities between the successful fixes, and distill them down to an answer, a panacea, the Xposed Philosopher's Stone, if you will.

So far, we have blacklisting our root-sensitive apps in EdXposed, along with the assorted Google Play apps (is there a list? I know of Google Play, Google Play Services, and Google Services Framework - are there others that absolutely MUST be in the blacklist?);

Add our apps and these Play services to Magiskhide;

Clear cache and data for Play services;

Reboot.

Some people claim success right here. Others have claimed deactivating all modules in EdXposed but leaving EdXposed active in Magisk does the trick, some people on XDA are still saying that the HiddenCore module in EdXposed actually works for GPay, others say it just spoofs the test somehow, and some folks are having good luck with the SQLite mod.

And of course there is the entirely different animal of DRM apps like Netflix, which don't seem to care if you can pass SafetyNet. I can watch Netflix on two LOS devices, and they both fail both tests in Magisk, but I cannot get Netflix working on my LOS phone, which CAN pass SafetyNet with blacklisting. There are two Magisk modules geared toward addressing this - Liboemcrypt Disabler, which worked great on my phone until I installed LineageOS, and SafetyPatch, which I believe works in conjunction with Didgeridoohan's Magiskhide Props Config module.

There has also been some discussion about the ancient module sudohide, if anyone wants to blow the dust off of it and precariously balance your phone's reliability on the tip of your nose.

Can we aggregate some of the other teks that people are using and see if we can locate a common denominator? Many people have this licked, and that tells us that it can be done. We have been communicating our various successes and failures, and that is good, but we are doing it in such a hodgepodge fashion that our results are very scattered.

We need lasers, coherent light sources, not D cell flashlights :)

[iamthekings5]

Please come back to the main subject.. edxposed tripping safetynet...
Issues with magisk or not related with safetynet shouldn't be on this thread

You said what everyone else was thinking. :)

Unfortunately it has been weeks now, and it does not look like EdXposed is likely to have a singular fix that will work for everyone on every device out of the box. It is beginning to look like we will have to work with what we currently have and know. We just need to find the commonalities between the successful fixes, and distill them down to an answer, a panacea, the Xposed Philosopher's Stone, if you will.

So far, we have blacklisting our root-sensitive apps in EdXposed, along with the assorted Google Play apps (is there a list? I know of Google Play, Google Play Services, and Google Services Framework - are there others that absolutely MUST be in the blacklist?);

Add our apps and these Play services to Magiskhide;

Clear cache and data for Play services;

Reboot.

Some people claim success right here. Others have claimed deactivating all _modules_ in EdXposed but leaving EdXposed active in Magisk does the trick, some people on XDA are still saying that the HiddenCore module in EdXposed actually works for GPay, others say it just spoofs the test somehow, and some folks are having good luck with the SQLite mod.

And of course there is the entirely different animal of DRM apps like Netflix, which don't seem to care if you can pass SafetyNet. I can watch Netflix on two LOS devices, and they both fail both tests in Magisk, but I cannot get Netflix working on my LOS phone, which CAN pass SafetyNet with blacklisting. There are two Magisk modules geared toward addressing this - Liboemcrypt Disabler, which worked great on my phone until I installed LineageOS, and SafetyPatch, which I believe works in conjunction with Didgeridoohan's Magiskhide Props Config module.

There has also been some discussion about the ancient module sudohide, if anyone wants to blow the dust off of it and precariously balance your phone's reliability on the tip of your nose.

Can we aggregate some of the other teks that people are using and see if we can locate a common denominator? Many people have this licked, and that tells us that it can be done. We have been communicating our various successes and failures, and that is good, but we are doing it in such a hodgepodge fashion that our results are very scattered.

We need lasers, coherent light sources, not D cell flashlights :)

I can't speak for Netflix because I don't know much about its DRM, but after I applied the temporary fix I can update Netflix and Revolut (which won't show if safetynet is not passed).

Specs:
1) EdXposed v0.4.5.1_beta(4463) (SandHook), was on YAFHA variant when issues first surfaced, tried to switch to SandHook to fix, no dice.
2) S10+ on Android Pie 9.0, Project Pixel 1.0, Magisk v19.3

What I tried:
1) As mentioned above, tried both variants of v0.4.5.1 of SandHook and YAFHA, both safetynet wasn't passing.
2) Tried previous versions of Sandhook, i think v0.4.4.4, no dice.
3) Tried advanced versions of Sandhook, the alpha files, no dice.

What (reliably) worked:
Blacklisting the following apps (on EdXposed): Google Services Framework, Google Play Store, Google Play services. To my knowledge if you leave even one of them unlisted safetynet will always fail. ALWAYS.

By blacklisting those 3 applications, I got safetynet to pass BUT!! it seems sporadic and random in nature. Sometimes it would say okay, sometimes i'd see the crosses. For me, this is a good enough bandaid until something meaningful comes along.

For Google Pay, I couldn't get it to work (it disabled my cards and I couldn't reactivate them), but after blacklisting Google Pay and Google, I eventually managed to re-enable all my cards and not get the this device is rooted warning. I will point out that sometimes it states that I'm rooted, indicating that the temporary fix we have is a bandaid solution.

All my xposed modules are working well, so for now this is fine.

Let me know if you have any questions! And please contribute to this.

Btw, I think Sudohide is pretty damn reiable! The problem is the framework it is build on has to constantly adapt.

[iamthekings5]

If you need secured apps that are from playstore but you can't pass safetynet, try aurora store. They pull apks directly from google play

[flostingapplesauce]

Thank you, I hadn't seen Aurora before, this is fancy! Very handy, too.

When you blacklist those three apps, do you also put anything in Magisk Hide? I am now completely unable to pass SafetyNet even blacklisting then in both. It is not real important to me, I can watch Amazon on my lunch hour instead (heh), but it is still fun to try.

Didgeridoohan mentioned that adding too many apps to MagiskHide can cause instabilities, and I wonder if the same is true of EdXposed Blacklist. Blacklisting the wrong system apps might cause grief, and although that doesn't seem like an issue for us, this seemed like a good time to say it.

[iamthekings5]

Thank you, I hadn't seen Aurora before, this is fancy! Very handy, too.

When you blacklist those three apps, do you also put anything in Magisk Hide? I am now completely unable to pass SafetyNet even blacklisting then in both. It is not real important to me, I can watch Amazon on my lunch hour instead (heh), but it is still fun to try.

Didgeridoohan mentioned that adding too many apps to MagiskHide can cause instabilities, and I wonder if the same is true of EdXposed Blacklist. Blacklisting the wrong system apps might cause grief, and although that doesn't seem like an issue for us, this seemed like a good time to say it.

Yes - I additionally place Google Pay and the Google app in the blacklist.

I made it a point to test which apps MUST be in the blacklist, as I also think it might cause some nasty instabilities and interactions if you put too many apps in the blacklist.

[mirsella]

could edxposed manager have a stub apk like magisk in the latest release to hide it completely ? or it's not the manager who been detected ?

[tupac55]

Actually I've done some research and found that's it's Google Play Services being hooked by edxposed.. because taichi-magisk doesn't trip safetynet by default, it'll trip safetynet only if you tell to taichi app to hook Google Play Services .. which doesn't need to be hooked for 99% of Xposed module

Also when not hooked with taichi the safetynet pass and it's not random as app list mode in edxposed manager.. it successfully pass and stay like that

I'm liking taichi so far, very stable and modulable, also Dev have control about what module should work or not so there's no toxic module and also Dev are replying quickly in their GitHub

So I'm assuming to fix safetynet being tripped edxposed manager or the framework should unhook Google Play Services..

[flostingapplesauce]

I am liking Taichi too, except no support for theAFwall+ module. Add that and I will ditch EdXposed immediately.

[tupac55]

You have to ask in their website for adding support for module that isn't supported yet :) , i'll let you find as i don't want to disrespect edxposed dev by giving a link. I really hope that Edxposed will just let us unhook completely Google Play Services and fix that quick

[flostingapplesauce]

I had the FDE Magisk module installed when SafetyNet broke, so it hasn't fixed it. I actually thought it might be one of the things tripping SafetyNet and uninstalled it, but it didn't change anything. I also bought the .apk and tried it instead of the module, but it has no discernible effect on SafetyNet. Nice app, though.

I haven't decided which I prefer, FDE or L Speed, both are pretty cool, but that is another subject.

[mirsella]

the fde things is a pure coincidence, for me I got safetynet stable after uninstalling fde...
using yafha it work Everytime now

[tonycpsu]

I'm running the yafha build here, have blacklisted the Google services as suggested, and while Magisk reports my device passes SafetyNet, GPay is complaining about being rooted. It must be doing some other check. Going to disable EdXposed and see if that fixes GPay.

My concern about switching to Taichi is the fact that it's closed source. Not saying I'm reviewing every line of code of these modules, but it is concerning that the dev will publish some things but not others.

[ayush5harma]

I'm running the yafha build here, have blacklisted the Google services as suggested, and while Magisk reports my device passes SafetyNet, GPay is complaining about being rooted. It must be doing some other check. Going to disable EdXposed and see if that fixes GPay.

My concern about switching to Taichi is the fact that it's closed source. Not saying I'm reviewing every line of code of these modules, but it is concerning that the dev will publish some things but not others.

It scans for apps installed on device just use xprivacy and disable app's get application request

[tonycpsu]

It scans for apps installed on device just use xprivacy and disable app's get application request

Will give that a shot. Thank you.

[maragath]

It scans for apps installed on device just use xprivacy and disable app's get application request

Good. It wooks!!

[tgt26]

It scans for apps installed on device just use xprivacy and disable app's get application request

Good. It wooks!!

Were you able to use GPay after denying Get Applications permission?

[ayush5harma]

It scans for apps installed on device just use xprivacy and disable app's get application request

Good. It wooks!!

Were you able to use GPay after denying Get Applications permission?

Block getapps permission long with blacklisting apps as stated in above comments and you'll be able to do payments provided safetynet doesn't trip.

[maragath]

It scans for apps installed on device just use xprivacy and disable app's get application request

Good. It wooks!!

Were you able to use GPay after denying Get Applications permission?

Yes. I haven't been able to use Gpay with Edxposed running for more than one month. After denying 'Get Applications' with XprivacyLua yesterday I made a payment with GPay

[GauriSpears]

As for me, just blacklisting of Google Play Services was enough.
Asus One Plus, Android 9, installed Lucky Patcher with modded Google Play.

[MlgmXyysd]

Yeah! Same bug here (but I've found workaround!)
Here:
Lineage OS 16 (Android 9)
Newest Official Magisk Canary:
20.2 (20102)
Manager 7.4.1 (255)
Manager Hidden
Newest EdXposed Manager v4.5.1
Newest Riru v19.5
Newest UNOFFICIAL EdXposed v0.4.6.0 beta (4471) SandHook (by Dark_Eyes_ at XDA Forum, to run with official Magisk)
Google Play Store v17.3.16
Lots of modules, including system wide XprivacyLua, Xposed Edge Pro,.....
SafetyNet completely broken in Magisk check. Both CTS and BasicIntegrity fail.
WORKAROUND: after turn on EdXposed Manager Black List feature and turn it on for Play Store, Play Services and Google Framework, SafetyNet becomes all green again! :) Try it!
Hope a fix. Thanks.

Oneplus 7 Pro
AOSiP-9.0-Official-guacamole-20190913
Magisk Canary 20.2 (20102)
Magisk Manager 7.4.1 (255) Hidden
EdXposed Manager v4.5.1
Riru - Core v19.5
Riru - EdXposed v0.4.6.0 SandHook
Google Play Store 17.3.16
Google Play Services 19.5.30
Thank you for your solution but it doesn't work though. Am I missing something? I opened EdXposed Manager then ->Application List -> toggle on "Google Play Store", "Google Play Services" (I have not found any "Google framework" though).
Update: open EdXposed Manager -> Settings -> toggle on "App List Mode" -> Application List -> toggle on "Google Play Store", "Google Play Services" -> reboot -> safetynet passed. Yay!

oh...only pass basicIntegrity on my phone...

Have you tried SafetyPatch or MagiskHide Props Config module?

well, passed

[robbyoconnor]

Does it stick?

On 12/19/19 4:01 AM, Jim Wu wrote:
>

            Yeah! Same bug here (but I've found workaround!)
            Here:
            Lineage OS 16 (Android 9)
            Newest Official Magisk Canary:
            20.2 (20102)
            Manager 7.4.1 (255)
            Manager Hidden
            Newest EdXposed Manager v4.5.1
            Newest Riru v19.5
            Newest UNOFFICIAL EdXposed v0.4.6.0 beta (4471)
            SandHook (by Dark_Eyes_ at XDA Forum, to run with
            official Magisk)
            Google Play Store v17.3.16
            Lots of modules, including system wide XprivacyLua,
            Xposed Edge Pro,.....
            SafetyNet completely broken in Magisk check. Both CTS
            and BasicIntegrity fail.
            WORKAROUND: after turn on EdXposed Manager Black List
            feature and turn it on for Play Store, Play Services
            and Google Framework, SafetyNet becomes all green
            again! :) Try it!
            Hope a fix. Thanks.

        Oneplus 7 Pro
        AOSiP-9.0-Official-guacamole-20190913
        Magisk Canary 20.2 (20102)
        Magisk Manager 7.4.1 (255) Hidden
        EdXposed Manager v4.5.1
        Riru - Core v19.5
        Riru - EdXposed v0.4.6.0 SandHook
        Google Play Store 17.3.16
        Google Play Services 19.5.30
        Thank you for your solution but it doesn't work though. Am
        I missing something? I opened EdXposed Manager then
        ->Application List -> toggle on "Google Play Store",
        "Google Play Services" (I have not found any "Google
        framework" though).
        Update: open EdXposed Manager -> Settings -> toggle on
        "App List Mode" -> Application List -> toggle on "Google
        Play Store", "Google Play Services" -> reboot -> safetynet
        passed. Yay!

    oh...only pass basicIntegrity on my phone...

Have you tried SafetyPatch or MagiskHide Props Config module?

well, passed

—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposed/issues/386?email_source=notifications&email_token=AAAFUMH7TYLHIOMIFUY7CU3QZM2AJA5CNFSM4JJOWDLKYY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEHI5JHA#issuecomment-567399580,
or unsubscribe
https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAAFUMCQCT2XYVY3PBQTDHDQZM2AJANCNFSM4JJOWDLA.

[tonycpsu]

The XPrivacyLua workaround to keep GPay from scanning apps worked for about a week, but now I'm getting the same "phone doesn't meet standards" error. Haven't added any other Magisk or XPosed modules or anything since then, so I think it's just getting more aggressive about how it scans.

OnePlus 6T, OxygenOS 9.0.17, Magisk 20.1, Ruru - EdXposed 0.4.5.1_beta(4463) (YAHFA)

[flostingapplesauce]

I don't use GPay so I cannot easily try, but would setting up Rikka's Storage Redirect app to allow granular Storage access to either Gpay or EdXposed work? Storage Redirect prevents apps from writing anywhere they please...

It would probably be WAY too complicated, if it works at all but meh, it might do something.

[tupac55]

As i said earlier, the only way to fix this safetynet issue is to unhook completly Google play Services.
You can also wipe dalvik and cache every reboot it'll pass.

No other way to fix this, i've tried every module that try to hide, and every option possible

[ayush5harma]

I don't use GPay so I cannot easily try, but would setting up Rikka's Storage Redirect app to allow granular Storage access to either Gpay or EdXposed work? Storage Redirect prevents apps from _writing_ anywhere they please...

It would probably be WAY too complicated, if it works at all but meh, it might do something.

gpay doesn't ask for storage permission

[nritech]

Ok so this time I installed Taichi module. Seems too simple and pretty straight forward with no edxposed kind of complexity.

• Do I need to install XPrivacyLua or Xprivacy to prevent issues with safetynet or triggering it? If so then what needs to be done?

• I only wanted xposed for using Xinsta thats it! Dont bother to use other modules.

• Also, what if for some reason Taichi conks off and I'm locked in a bootloop, is there an escape plan like uninstalling/resetting it via twrp?

[ikky-ba]

Ok so this time I installed Taichi module. Seems too simple and pretty straight forward with no edxposed kind of complexity.

• Do I need to install XPrivacyLua or Xprivacy to prevent issues with safetynet or triggering it? If so then what needs to be done?
• I only wanted xposed for using Xinsta thats it! Dont bother to use other modules.
• Also, what if for some reason Taichi conks off and I'm locked in a bootloop, is there an escape plan like uninstalling/resetting it via twrp?

You can erase the module going into /data/adb/modules on TWRP. I also have the same issue with Taichi, phone take more than 20 min to boot when it does.

Sad to see that both options to use xposededge are broken. I'm using OOS 10.3

[flostingapplesauce]

I don't use GPay so I cannot easily try, but would setting up Rikka's Storage Redirect app to allow granular Storage access to either Gpay or EdXposed work? Storage Redirect prevents apps from _writing_ anywhere they please...
It would probably be WAY too complicated, if it works at all but meh, it might do something.

gpay doesn't ask for storage permission

I was only thinking that some things that look for root do it by finding file evidence of root, log files, apps and the like. Storage Redirect confines apps from writing to anywhere other than where you specifically allow.

It was just a shot in the dark. Someone mentioned using some file hide utilities, and SR was that same thought from a different angle. It was far from a fully formed plan, though.

[flostingapplesauce]

Ok so this time I installed Taichi module. Seems too simple and pretty straight forward with no edxposed kind of complexity.

• Do I need to install XPrivacyLua or Xprivacy to prevent issues with safetynet or triggering it? If so then what needs to be done?
• I only wanted xposed for using Xinsta thats it! Dont bother to use other modules.
• Also, what if for some reason Taichi conks off and I'm locked in a bootloop, is there an escape plan like uninstalling/resetting it via twrp?

You could use MMRT to disable it, uninstall it or even enable Core Only. It doesn't install anything, just runs in memory. Run it by "Installing" it in TWRP.

https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/tool-magisk-manager-recovery-tool-v1-0-t3866502/amp/

[Dreamerrrr]

A few days ago I tried most of the fixes listed here and would swap between tripping and passing SafetyNet.

Today, I've done two things differently, and I haven't tripped SafetyNet yet with EdXposed + GravityBox + MinMinGuard + XPrivacyLua.

I updated this Magisk module (GPay-SQLite-Fix) and EdXposed Manager to 4.5.2.

I have Google Play Services, Google Play Store, Google Services Framework, and Carrier Services marked on EdXposed Black List and I do NOT have App List Mode enabled anymore.

I'll be watching my phone over the next few days to see if anything breaks.

EDIT: Over a week in. Still passing SafetyNet. Still certified in Play Store. Still have the ability to download apps like Netflix in Play Store. I forgot to mention I am also using the "SafetyPatch" Magisk module, but I was using that before I updated the GPay-SQLite-Fix module and would fail from time to time. Also using a custom kernel (ElementalX).

Please come back to the main subject.. edxposed tripping safetynet...
Issues with magisk or not related with safetynet shouldn't be on this thread

You said what everyone else was thinking. :)

Unfortunately it has been weeks now, and it does not look like EdXposed is likely to have a singular fix that will work for everyone on every device out of the box. It is beginning to look like we will have to work with what we currently have and know. We just need to find the commonalities between the successful fixes, and distill them down to an answer, a panacea, the Xposed Philosopher's Stone, if you will.

So far, we have blacklisting our root-sensitive apps in EdXposed, along with the assorted Google Play apps (is there a list? I know of Google Play, Google Play Services, and Google Services Framework - are there others that absolutely MUST be in the blacklist?);

Add our apps and these Play services to Magiskhide;

Clear cache and data for Play services;

Reboot.

Some people claim success right here. Others have claimed deactivating all _modules_ in EdXposed but leaving EdXposed active in Magisk does the trick, some people on XDA are still saying that the HiddenCore module in EdXposed actually works for GPay, others say it just spoofs the test somehow, and some folks are having good luck with the SQLite mod.

And of course there is the entirely different animal of DRM apps like Netflix, which don't seem to care if you can pass SafetyNet. I can watch Netflix on two LOS devices, and they both fail both tests in Magisk, but I cannot get Netflix working on my LOS phone, which CAN pass SafetyNet with blacklisting. There are two Magisk modules geared toward addressing this - Liboemcrypt Disabler, which worked great on my phone until I installed LineageOS, and SafetyPatch, which I believe works in conjunction with Didgeridoohan's Magiskhide Props Config module.

There has also been some discussion about the ancient module sudohide, if anyone wants to blow the dust off of it and precariously balance your phone's reliability on the tip of your nose.

Can we aggregate some of the other teks that people are using and see if we can locate a common denominator? Many people have this licked, and that tells us that it can be done. We have been communicating our various successes and failures, and that is good, but we are doing it in such a hodgepodge fashion that our results are very scattered.

We need lasers, coherent light sources, not D cell flashlights :)

I'm still passing SafetyNet, have Netflix installed with Widevine L1 access, and can use Google Pay. I also updated from the November patch to the December patch and got SafetyNet back after updating my kernel/reinstalling Magisk. Pixel 3a, stock ROM + Magisk + EdXposed.

Kernel:
Elemental X

Magisk Modules:
GPay SQLite Fix
Riru Core
EdXposed v4.6.0_beta (YAHFA)
SQLite for ARM aarch64 devices
SafetyPatch

Magisk Hide:
Google Pay
Google Play Services
Google Services Framework
Netflix

Xposed Modules:
Gravity Box
MinMinGuard
XPrivacy Lua (denying most apps the "get applications" permission including GPay. Play Services/Google Service Framework currently are allowed all permissions.)

Xposed Blacklist:
Google Play Services
Google Services Framework
Google Play Store
Carrier Services

I bolded all my settings that I think actually affect whether or not I pass SafetyNet and can use GPay.

I used GPay on Dec. 19 with no problems and Netflix is still in my Play Store. Device is Play Protect certified as well.

[nritech]

Will untested modules work with Taichi?
Such as Flat Style Bar Indicators, Xstana etc.

[MlgmXyysd]

Will untested modules work with Taichi?
Such as Flat Style Bar Indicators, Xstana etc.

do not use TaiChi anyway
https://forum.xda-developers.com/xposed/warning-taichi-t4012681

[flostingapplesauce]

Will untested modules work with Taichi?
Such as Flat Style Bar Indicators, Xstana etc.

do not use TaiChi anyway
https://forum.xda-developers.com/xposed/warning-taichi-t4012681

Thank you for posting that. Very elucidating.

[tupac55]

Will untested modules work with Taichi?
Such as Flat Style Bar Indicators, Xstana etc.

do not use TaiChi anyway
https://forum.xda-developers.com/xposed/warning-taichi-t4012681

Can you make a way to totally unhook Google play services then ? As it what is solve the issue ..

[MlgmXyysd]

@tupac55 Turn on the "App list mode" in Settings -> Add gms and gsf to Black List(Application List tab) -> install SafetyPatch or MagiskHideProp module in Magisk(optical) -> Reboot

[Sy1er]

@MlgmXyysd any workaround for sudohide to hide updates from play store? It apparently does not work when I add GPS and GSF to blacklist

[MlgmXyysd]

@Sy1er Google Play Services(gms) and Google Services Framework(gsf)

[Sy1er]

@MlgmXyysd yes added gsm and gsf but sudohide stopped working. is it due to blacklisting gsm and gsf or there might be some other issue with it? Also do I need the custom magisk on OnePlus 7 device running android 10? Thanks for the reply.

[MlgmXyysd]

@Sy1er Use Magisk Manager to check SafetyNet

[Senliast]

So, it is impossible to find out, what does SafetyNet exaclty detects by EdXposed?

[MlgmXyysd]

@Senliast Because EdXposed hooked related components of SafetyNet

[ayush5harma]

It scans for apps installed on device just use xprivacy and disable app's get application request

Good. It wooks!!

Were you able to use GPay after denying Get Applications permission?

Yes. I haven't been able to use Gpay with Edxposed running for more than one month. After denying 'Get Applications' with XprivacyLua yesterday I made a payment with GPay

Use Gpay sqlite fix along with applist magiskhide and xprivacy lua.Gpay working for me with them.

[ayush5harma]

A few days ago I tried most of the fixes listed here and would swap between tripping and passing SafetyNet.
Today, I've done two things differently, and I haven't tripped SafetyNet yet with EdXposed + GravityBox + MinMinGuard + XPrivacyLua.
I updated this Magisk module (GPay-SQLite-Fix) and EdXposed Manager to 4.5.2.
I have Google Play Services, Google Play Store, Google Services Framework, and Carrier Services marked on EdXposed Black List and I do NOT have App List Mode enabled anymore.
I'll be watching my phone over the next few days to see if anything breaks.
EDIT: Over a week in. Still passing SafetyNet. Still certified in Play Store. Still have the ability to download apps like Netflix in Play Store. I forgot to mention I am also using the "SafetyPatch" Magisk module, but I was using that before I updated the GPay-SQLite-Fix module and would fail from time to time. Also using a custom kernel (ElementalX).

Please come back to the main subject.. edxposed tripping safetynet...
Issues with magisk or not related with safetynet shouldn't be on this thread

You said what everyone else was thinking. :)
Unfortunately it has been weeks now, and it does not look like EdXposed is likely to have a singular fix that will work for everyone on every device out of the box. It is beginning to look like we will have to work with what we currently have and know. We just need to find the commonalities between the successful fixes, and distill them down to an answer, a panacea, the Xposed Philosopher's Stone, if you will.
So far, we have blacklisting our root-sensitive apps in EdXposed, along with the assorted Google Play apps (is there a list? I know of Google Play, Google Play Services, and Google Services Framework - are there others that absolutely MUST be in the blacklist?);
Add our apps and these Play services to Magiskhide;
Clear cache and data for Play services;
Reboot.
Some people claim success right here. Others have claimed deactivating all _modules_ in EdXposed but leaving EdXposed active in Magisk does the trick, some people on XDA are still saying that the HiddenCore module in EdXposed actually works for GPay, others say it just spoofs the test somehow, and some folks are having good luck with the SQLite mod.
And of course there is the entirely different animal of DRM apps like Netflix, which don't seem to care if you can pass SafetyNet. I can watch Netflix on two LOS devices, and they both fail both tests in Magisk, but I cannot get Netflix working on my LOS phone, which CAN pass SafetyNet with blacklisting. There are two Magisk modules geared toward addressing this - Liboemcrypt Disabler, which worked great on my phone until I installed LineageOS, and SafetyPatch, which I believe works in conjunction with Didgeridoohan's Magiskhide Props Config module.
There has also been some discussion about the ancient module sudohide, if anyone wants to blow the dust off of it and precariously balance your phone's reliability on the tip of your nose.
Can we aggregate some of the other teks that people are using and see if we can locate a common denominator? Many people have this licked, and that tells us that it can be done. We have been communicating our various successes and failures, and that is good, but we are doing it in such a hodgepodge fashion that our results are very scattered.
We need lasers, coherent light sources, not D cell flashlights :)

I'm still passing SafetyNet, have Netflix installed with Widevine L1 access, and can use Google Pay. I also updated from the November patch to the December patch and got SafetyNet back after updating my kernel/reinstalling Magisk. Pixel 3a, stock ROM + Magisk + EdXposed.

Kernel:
Elemental X

Magisk Modules:
GPay SQLite Fix
Riru Core
EdXposed v4.6.0_beta (YAHFA)
SQLite for ARM aarch64 devices
SafetyPatch

Magisk Hide:
Google Pay
Google Play Services
Google Services Framework
Netflix

Xposed Modules:
Gravity Box
MinMinGuard
XPrivacy Lua (denying most apps the "get applications" permission including GPay. Play Services/Google Service Framework currently are allowed all permissions.)

Xposed Blacklist:
Google Play Services
Google Services Framework
Google Play Store
Carrier Services

I bolded all my settings that I think actually affect whether or not I pass SafetyNet and can use GPay.

I used GPay on Dec. 19 with no problems and Netflix is still in my Play Store. Device is Play Protect certified as well.

Thanks my gpay stopped working after the latest update uptill then it was working with applist magiskhide and xprivacy blocking.Flashing Gpay sqlitefix made it work again.

[Sy1er]

@Sy1er Google Play Services(gms) and Google Services Framework(gsf)

I am passing safety net but sudohide module doesn't work with GSF and GMS enabled any work around for it

[refi64]

I had initially used XPrivacyLua on Google Pay and myStudentAid to prevent them from seeing Magisk Manager and Edxposed Installer, but I couldn't get either GPay not myStudentAid working. However, at the moment, leaving Edxposed Installer as-is and having Magisk Manager hide itself seems to have done the trick for now.

My best guess would be maybe they realized that XPrivacyLua's default return empty application list return value isn't legit? (I'd think this could be worked around though...)

[devanteweary]

Using Riru - Core v19.5 and Riru - EdXposed v0.4.5.1_beta(4463) (SandHook).

If I enable a module in EdXposed Manager, games like Dragalia Lost won't work and Magisk tests fail.

However if I disable (not uninstall) the modules, the Magisk tests and anti-root games work just fine.

Doesn't matter the EdXposed module, just that they are enabled.

[devanteweary]

Just an update.

With the new EdXposed Manager update from yesterday, everything works fine with the "Pass Safetynet" option turned on and App List mode enabled.

Thanks guys!

[tgt26]

Just an update.

With the new EdXposed Manager update from yesterday, everything works fine with the "Pass Safetynet" option turned on and App List mode enabled.

Thanks guys!

Does GPay work?

[devanteweary]

Does GPay work?

I just installed it as a test for you and hid with both the latest EdXposed manager and Magisk (root is 19.4) and it failed. Actually told me the phone may be rooted.

Well my test was getting Dragalia Lost running which does now plus having Magisk pass those two tests which it does.

[reyqn]

Gpay does work, you just have to use the Gpay sqlite fix (magisk module)

[tonycpsu]

With the following environment:

OnePlus 6T
Android 10
Magisk 20.1
Magisk Manager 7.5.1-1, renamed to avoid detection
Riru Core 19.5
Riru - EdXposed 0.4.6.0_beta(4471) (YAHFA)
Magisk Hide for Google Pay, Google Play Store, Google Play Services, Google Services Framework
EdXposed blacklisting Google Pay, Google Play Store, Google Play Services, and Google Services Framework
XPrivacyLua blocking Application List for Google Pay, Google Play Store, Google Play Services, and Google Services Framework

I am able to get GPay working intermittently. For 2-3 days, it'll work fine, then it'll give me the "your device isn't ready for contactless payments" message. Then out of nowhere that goes away and it works fine again. Had this cycle repeat a few times already. Seems like it's still detecting root despite all of these countermeasures.

[elzafir]

My problems:

• SafetyNet failed, both ctsProfile and basicIntegrity failed
• Netflix is not available in Play Store (a sign that SafetyNet is tripped)

My solution:

Device: Xiaomi Mi A2 (jasmine_sprout)
ROM: Havoc-OS v2.8 (Android 9 Pie)

Magisk

• _Magisk_: Magisk v20.3, Magisk Manager 7.5.1
• _Magisk Manager - Settings_: Hide Magisk Manager (Repackage; I renamed it to "Manager")
• _Magisk Modules_: GPay SQLite Fix (Full Edition), MagiskHide Props Config, Busybox for Android NDK, Riru - Core v19.6, Riru - EdXposed v0.4.5.1
• _MagiskHide Props Config Module_: From terminal emulator, choose 1. Edit device Fingerprint, then choose f. Pick a certified fingerprint, then set fingerprint to Pixel 4 XL (or other fingerprint of your choosing, even your device own fingerprint, it might work)
• _Magisk Hide_: Google Play Services, Google Play Store, Google Services Framework

_Notes_:

• Installing only MagiskHide Props Config (MHPC) without GPay SQLite Fix makes SafetyNet both ctsProfile & basicIntegrity pass, but Netflix is still not found in Play Store. Set MHPC by going to terminal emulator (I use Termux) and typing "su", then "props".
• Installing only GPay SQLite Fix without MHPC results in ctsProfile failed but basicIntegrity pass. Installing with MHPC makes both SafetyNet pass AND makes Netflix available in Play Store
• Busybox is required for MHPC module and Busybox by itself is known to break SafetyNet

EdXposed

• _EdXposed_: EdXposed v0.4.5.1_beta(4463) (YAHFA), EdXposed Manager 4.5.3
• _EdXposed Manager - Settings_: App List Mode (ON), Pass SafetyNet (ON)
• _EdXposed Manager - Application/Black List_: Google Play Services, Google Services Framework

_Notes:_

• Black listing without MHPC and GPay SQLite Fix only make SafetyNet pass basicIntegrity, but not ctsProfile.
• I didn't black list Google Play Store in EdXposed because that would break SudoHide module, which I need for hiding YouTube Vanced and Instagram from Play Store to prevent it from updating. If you don't use SudoHide, you can black list Google Play Store just in case.

Then, clear data & cache from Google Play Store and Google Play Services and reboot.

_Results_

• _SafetyNet_: ctsProfile: true, basicIntegrity: true.
• _Play Protect_: No problems found.
• _Netflix_: is available to download and install in Play Store.
• _Google Pay_: not tested as it's not available in my country and my phone lacks NFC anyway.

Let me know if this works for you.

EDIT:

• Updating to Magisk 20.3 from 20.2 made me fail ctsProfile in SafetyNet.
• After experimenting, I can now conclude that we don't need to block com.google.android.gms.setup and Google Play Store from EdXposed.
• Also, MagiskHide Props Config and changing fingerprint is definitely needed.
• After updating Magisk, what I did was: redo set fingerprint in MHPC, and clear data & cache from Play Store and Google Play Services, then reboot. If it doesn't work, try uninstalling both MHPC and GPay SQLite Fix and redo the process. Should work.

[NTICompass]

Just something I wanted to mention. I was using Magisk/EdXposed on Android 9 and Google Pay was working fine, even in-store payments. Now, on Android 10, I've noticed that sometimes SafetyNet (in Magisk) says I'm fine and other times it says I'm not.

I can reboot, add cards to Google Pay, but then when I tap to pay, it fails. I am just going to wait to see what updates to Magisk, EdXposed, etc. are created to fix this on Android 10. I wish I could help, but I'm not sure what I can do.

[shmykelsa]

Same as @NTICompass

[SoumyBhow]

My problems:

• SafetyNet failed, both ctsProfile and basicIntegrity
• Netflix is not available in Play Store

My solution:

Device: Xiaomi Mi A2 (jasmine_sprout)
ROM: Havoc-OS v2.8 (Android 9 Pie)

Magisk

• _Magisk_: Magisk v20.2, Magisk Manager 7.5.0
• _Magisk Manager - Settings_: Hide Magisk Manager (Repackage)
• _Magisk Modules_: Busybox for Android NDK, GPay SQLite Fix (Full Edition / _This makes Netflix available in Play Store_), MagiskHide Props Config v5.1.0-v71, Riru - Core v19.6, Riru - EdXposed v0.4.5.1
• _MagiskHide Props Config Module_: Fingerprint set to _Pixel 4 XL_ (_this makes SafetyNet pass, but Netfllix still not found in Play Store, installing GPay SQLite Fix Full Edition fixed it; now I'm not sure if MHPC is needed?_)
• _Magisk Hide_: Google Play Services, Google Play Store, Google Services Framework

EdXposed

• _EdXposed_: EdXposed v0.4.5.1_beta(4463) (YAHFA), EdXposed Manager 4.5.3
• _EdXposed Modules_: SudoHide (_works_)
• _EdXposed Manager - Settings_: App List Mode (ON), Pass SafetyNet (ON)
• _EdXposed Manager - Application/Black List_: com.google.android.gms.setup, Google Play Services, Google Services Framework (_black listing without MHPC and GPay SQLite Fix only make SafetyNet pass basicIntegrity, but not ctsProfile_)

Note: I didn't black list Google Play Store in EdXposed because that would break SudoHide module, which I need for hiding YouTube Vanced and older Instagram version that works InstaPrefs from Play Store to prevent it from updating.

Then, clear data & cache from Google Play Store and Google Play Services and reboot.

_Results_

• _SafetyNet_: ctsProfile: true, basicIntegrity: true.
• _Play Protect_: No problems found.
• _Netflix_: is available to download and install in Play Store.
• _Google Pay_: not tested as it's not available in my country and my phone lacks NFC anyway.

Let me know if this works for you.

Thank you for these instructions! They work quite well on my Oneplus 7 Pro running Android 10. However, Edxposed's App List Mode breaks the Volume Key Cursor Control feature on Gravitybox. Is there an alternative method to pass SafetyNet that doesn't require App List Mode to be enabled in Edxposed Manager? Also, on a side-note, what is the Compat List used for in Edxposed Manager. I couldn't find any info on it online. Sorry if that question is unrelated...

EDIT: I use SudoHide to hide Youtube Vanced and GBoard from the Play Store. After enabling App List mode that doesn't work anymore.

[MlgmXyysd]

@LegionSSH this module seems only hook MagiskManager and got success

[SoumyBhow]

Use HiddenCore Module in edXposed

Is that the only way? I tried it before and it only spoofs the pass. Maybe I'll go back again. I don't use GPay or Netflix. Thanks!

[elzafir]

Thank you for these instructions! They work quite well on my Oneplus 7 Pro running Android 10. However, Edxposed's App List Mode breaks the Volume Key Cursor Control feature on Gravitybox. Is there an alternative method to pass SafetyNet that doesn't require App List Mode to be enabled in Edxposed Manager? Also, on a side-note, what is the Compat List used for in Edxposed Manager. I couldn't find any info on it online. Sorry if that question is unrelated...

Unfortunately, I haven't found a way to pass SafetyNet without EdXposed blacklist feature (which requires turning on App List on EdXposed Manager settings). I think it's essential to hide EdXposed from GMS and GSF for now, unless ElderDrivers could find a way to hardcode hiding EdXposed from GMS & GSF without having to enable App List.

EDIT: I use SudoHide to hide Youtube Vanced and GBoard from the Play Store. After enabling App List mode that doesn't work anymore.

I also use SudoHide. In my case, without App List, activating SudoHide results in bootloop, at least on my device and setup. With App List, I experience no bootloop. But that's beside the point. Did you block _Google Play Store_ in EdXposed? Because if you do that, then SudoHide won't be able to hide apps from Play Store to prevent it from updating.

[elzafir]

Use HiddenCore Module in edXposed

Is that the only way? I tried it before and it only spoofs the pass. Maybe I'll go back again. I don't use GPay or Netflix. Thanks!

I also read that HiddenCore is just a placebo. If you do try it, why not try to find and install Netflix on Play Store? If SafetyNet fails, then Netflix won't even turn up in search results.

[MlgmXyysd]

@elzafir no, my snet is passed, but netflix wont shown
cause by cts not passed

[SoumyBhow]

Thank you for these instructions! They work quite well on my Oneplus 7 Pro running Android 10. However, Edxposed's App List Mode breaks the Volume Key Cursor Control feature on Gravitybox. Is there an alternative method to pass SafetyNet that doesn't require App List Mode to be enabled in Edxposed Manager? Also, on a side-note, what is the Compat List used for in Edxposed Manager. I couldn't find any info on it online. Sorry if that question is unrelated...

Unfortunately, I haven't found a way to pass SafetyNet without EdXposed blacklist feature (which requires turning on App List on EdXposed Manager settings). I think it's essential to hide EdXposed from GMS and GSF for now, unless ElderDrivers could find a way to hardcode hiding EdXposed from GMS & GSF without having to enable App List.

EDIT: I use SudoHide to hide Youtube Vanced and GBoard from the Play Store. After enabling App List mode that doesn't work anymore.

I also use SudoHide. In my case, without App List, activating SudoHide results in bootloop, at least on my device and setup. With App List, I experience no bootloop. But that's beside the point. Did you block _Google Play Store_ in EdXposed? Because if you do that, then SudoHide won't be able to hide apps from Play Store to prevent it from updating.

I've been using this "latest" version of SudoHide (https://github.com/Mikanoshi/SudoHide/releases). Maybe that's it. Are you sure you are able to hide apps from Play Store with App List mode enabled?

Edit: I've tried Hidden Core again, and I can still install Netflix from Play Store. YouTube is hidden from Play Store using that aforementioned SudoHide 1.28.3. Safety net obviously passes in Magisk Manager. This is unexpected, but I'll take it!

Edit 2: nevermind. Netflix is gone again. Oh well.

[NTICompass]

I tried using Google Pay in-store today and it worked. It seems like sometimes SafetyNet works and sometimes it doesn't.
This is on Android 10 with 0.4.6.0 beta.
Annoyingly, the Play Store still says it's uncertified.

[elzafir]

Thank you for these instructions! They work quite well on my Oneplus 7 Pro running Android 10. However, Edxposed's App List Mode breaks the Volume Key Cursor Control feature on Gravitybox. Is there an alternative method to pass SafetyNet that doesn't require App List Mode to be enabled in Edxposed Manager? Also, on a side-note, what is the Compat List used for in Edxposed Manager. I couldn't find any info on it online. Sorry if that question is unrelated...

Unfortunately, I haven't found a way to pass SafetyNet without EdXposed blacklist feature (which requires turning on App List on EdXposed Manager settings). I think it's essential to hide EdXposed from GMS and GSF for now, unless ElderDrivers could find a way to hardcode hiding EdXposed from GMS & GSF without having to enable App List.

EDIT: I use SudoHide to hide Youtube Vanced and GBoard from the Play Store. After enabling App List mode that doesn't work anymore.

I also use SudoHide. In my case, without App List, activating SudoHide results in bootloop, at least on my device and setup. With App List, I experience no bootloop. But that's beside the point. Did you block _Google Play Store_ in EdXposed? Because if you do that, then SudoHide won't be able to hide apps from Play Store to prevent it from updating.

I've been using this "latest" version of SudoHide (https://github.com/Mikanoshi/SudoHide/releases). Maybe that's it. Are you sure you are able to hide apps from Play Store with App List mode enabled?

I'm using SudoHide 1.28 that's in EdXposed repo from 2017. Yes, my SudoHide works perfect with App List enabled. In fact, if I disable App List, my phone would go into bootloop (here is someone suggesting turning on App List to prevent bootloop for SudoHide https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=79975110&postcount=227)

I haven't tried the latest 1.28.3 from September 2019. I'll try it tomorrow and see if it also works with App List mode enabled.

[hsheidaryarad]

hi guys, use,exposed installer version 2.2.5 from solohsu smd safetynet papass easily passed and work

[SoumyBhow]

I switched to the old version of SudoHide in Xposed repo and I think I'm finally passing Safety net for real (with App List mode and Pass Safetynet enabled in Edxposed Manager settings). I couldn't get this SudoHide to work before because I kept enabling 'hide from system apps' when I was hiding YouTube from Google Play Store, which caused YouTube to crash. Force Stopping and wiping Google Play Store and Services brought Netflix back. Gravitybox Volume Keyboard cursor no longer works, but I'll get used to that.

[SoumyBhow]

I switched to the old version of SudoHide in Xposed repo and I think I'm finally passing Safety net for real (with App List mode and Pass Safetynet enabled in Edxposed Manager settings). I couldn't get this SudoHide to work before because I kept enabling 'hide from system apps' when I was hiding YouTube from Google Play Store, which caused YouTube to crash. Force Stopping and wiping Google Play Store and Services brought Netflix back. Gravitybox Volume Keyboard cursor no longer works, but I'll get used to that.
Edit: Dang it's gone again :(

[drewcu]

I switched to the old version of SudoHide in Xposed repo and I think I'm finally passing Safety net for real (with App List mode and Pass Safetynet enabled in Edxposed Manager settings). I couldn't get this SudoHide to work before because I kept enabling 'hide from system apps' when I was hiding YouTube from Google Play Store, which caused YouTube to crash. Force Stopping and wiping Google Play Store and Services brought Netflix back. Gravitybox Volume Keyboard cursor no longer works, but I'll get used to that.

I've never really used SudoHide before and am not sure I know what I should expect to see when I hide Youtube Vanced from the Play Store. I have SudoHide 1.28.3 installed and hid Vanced from the Store and rebooted. I still see Youtube in the Store with 2 options - Open and Update, which is what I saw before I used SudoHide. Like you, I had checked off "hide from system apps" and Vanced wouldn't open. Thanks to your suggestion, I took that option off and Vanced now opens. Ideally I could enable Store auto updates again for all apps and Youtube wouldn't overwrite Vanced with the original version, but thus far I've yet to find a solution that allows that. I use enable_detach in cache and while it mostly hides Youtube, every once in a while it appears and updates on its own.

Be awesome if you could put together a list of all things it takes to get Safetynet to pass 100% of the time. Normally for me, it fails right after boot, then I close Magisk and a couple minutes later it passes. Then I try again later and it fails and closing Magisk and opening it again allows it to pass. Very sporadic. Now I see your latest update and it seems you haven't found a true Safetynet solution either. Perhaps you can still help me with Vanced and the Store?

Thanks!

[SoumyBhow]

I switched to the old version of SudoHide in Xposed repo and I think I'm finally passing Safety net for real (with App List mode and Pass Safetynet enabled in Edxposed Manager settings). I couldn't get this SudoHide to work before because I kept enabling 'hide from system apps' when I was hiding YouTube from Google Play Store, which caused YouTube to crash. Force Stopping and wiping Google Play Store and Services brought Netflix back. Gravitybox Volume Keyboard cursor no longer works, but I'll get used to that.

I've never really used SudoHide before and am not sure I know what I should expect to see when I hide Youtube Vanced from the Play Store. I have SudoHide 1.28.3 installed and hid Vanced from the Store and rebooted. I still see Youtube in the Store with 2 options - Open and Update, which is what I saw before I used SudoHide. Like you, I had checked off "hide from system apps" and Vanced wouldn't open. Thanks to your suggestion, I took that option off and Vanced now opens. Ideally I could enable Store auto updates again for all apps and Youtube wouldn't overwrite Vanced with the original version, but thus far I've yet to find a solution that allows that. I use enable_detach in cache and while it mostly hides Youtube, every once in a while it appears and updates on its own.

Be awesome if you could put together a list of all things it takes to get Safetynet to pass 100% of the time. Normally for me, it fails right after boot, then I close Magisk and a couple minutes later it passes. Then I try again later and it fails and closing Magisk and opening it again allows it to pass. Very sporadic. Now I see your latest update and it seems you haven't found a true Safetynet solution either. Perhaps you can still help me with Vanced and the Store?

Thanks!
Try the original version of SudoHide from the Edxposed repo. That's what I'm using, and it works with App List mode enabled. In SudoHide, select YouTube Vance's first in the list (enable system apps in 3 dot menu) then select Play Store, save changes and reboot. That's what I did.

I tried the safety Net instructions a couple of posts above mine with the GPay Sqlite module. In theory they're supposed to work, but mine seems to go off and on too...

[drewcu]

Try the original version of SudoHide from the Edxposed repo. That's what I'm using, and it works with App List mode enabled. In SudoHide, select YouTube Vance's first in the list (enable system apps in 3 dot menu) then select Play Store, save changes and reboot. That's what I did.

I used that version originally and experienced the same thing. What I'm asking is how do you know SudoHide is working? What happens when you search for Youtube in the Store? Does the Store show Youtube with Open/Update options or not even show Youtube at all? After getting SudoHide set up my Store still shows Youtube with Open/Update options just like before I installed SudoHide. I'm not sure if my situation is different from most in that Youtube is a system app on my LG V30 VS996 stock, but maybe that's how it always is.

[elzafir]

Try the original version of SudoHide from the Edxposed repo. That's what I'm using, and it works with App List mode enabled. In SudoHide, select YouTube Vance's first in the list (enable system apps in 3 dot menu) then select Play Store, save changes and reboot. That's what I did.

I used that version originally and experienced the same thing. What I'm asking is how do you know SudoHide is working? What happens when you search for Youtube in the Store? Does the Store show Youtube with Open/Update options or not even show Youtube at all? After getting SudoHide set up my Store still shows Youtube with Open/Update options just like before I installed SudoHide. I'm not sure if my situation is different from most in that Youtube is a system app on my LG V30 VS996 stock, but maybe that's how it always is.

In my case, with SudoHide hiding Vanced from Google Play Store, I can still find YouTube in the Play Store, but it simply says "Install".

If you already have Magisk, why not systemlessly debloat YouTube using Debloater module so it's no longer a system app to prevent any conflict with Vanced?

[drewcu]

In my case, with SudoHide hiding Vanced from Google Play Store, I can still find YouTube in the Play Store, but it simply says "Install".

If you already have Magisk, why not systemlessly debloat YouTube using Debloater module so it's no longer a system app to prevent any conflict with Vanced?

Thanks for that suggestion which I completed and also uninstalled Vanced. Now the Youtube in the Store only gives the option for "Install" indicating it's Uninstalled instead of Open/Update before using Debloater.

I then installed Vanced and set SudoHide 1.28.3 to hide Vanced from the Store. However, in the Store I again see the options to Open/Update Youtube -- not "Install" like I'd expect if SudoHide was really working. When I install SudoHide 1.28 via EdXposed, it won't detect the Xposed framework which is why I tried 1.28.3. I'm not sure why SudoHide doesn't work for me at this point. I do have App List and Safetynet Pass settings enabled within Manager FYI.

Sorry to hijack this thread re: SudoHide/Youtube, but I feel like I'm close and hopefully one more suggestion solves the puzzle for me/anyone else in my boat.

Thanks!

EDIT:
For me with App List Mode DISABLED, SudoHide 1.28.3 successfully hides Youtube from Play Store (Install option is shown). However, Safetynet fails every time.

With App List Mode ENABLED, Safetynet is able to pass (randomly), but SudoHide 1.28.3 does not hide Youtube from Play Store (Open/Update options shown).

So it seems there's a trade-off between Safetynet passing and SudoHide working (Vanced hidden from Play Store). Would be nice to have apps auto update in the Store again so I may disable App List Mode and have Safetynet fail...

[SoumyBhow]

In my case, with SudoHide hiding Vanced from Google Play Store, I can still find YouTube in the Play Store, but it simply says "Install".
If you already have Magisk, why not systemlessly debloat YouTube using Debloater module so it's no longer a system app to prevent any conflict with Vanced?

Thanks for that suggestion which I completed and also uninstalled Vanced. Now the Youtube in the Store only gives the option for "Install" indicating it's Uninstalled instead of Open/Update before using Debloater.

I then installed Vanced and set SudoHide 1.28.3 to hide Vanced from the Store. However, in the Store I again see the options to Open/Update Youtube -- not "Install" like I'd expect if SudoHide was really working. When I install SudoHide 1.28 via EdXposed, it won't detect the Xposed framework which is why I tried 1.28.3. I'm not sure why SudoHide doesn't work for me at this point. I do have App List and Safetynet Pass settings enabled within Manager FYI.

Sorry to hijack this thread re: SudoHide/Youtube, but I feel like I'm close and hopefully one more suggestion solves the puzzle for me/anyone else in my boat.

Thanks!

EDIT:
For me with App List Mode DISABLED, SudoHide 1.28.3 successfully hides Youtube from Play Store (Install option is shown). However, Safetynet fails every time.

With App List Mode ENABLED, Safetynet is able to pass (randomly), but SudoHide 1.28.3 does not hide Youtube from Play Store (Open/Update options shown).

So it seems there's a trade-off between Safetynet passing and SudoHide working (Vanced hidden from Play Store). Would be nice to have apps auto update in the Store again so I may disable App List Mode and have Safetynet fail...

The original SudoHide 1.28 works for me even with App List Mode enabled. It's been a couple of hours and I can still install Netflix from Play Store, so I am confident I'm passing SafetyNet.

[drewcu]

The original SudoHide 1.28 works for me even with App List Mode enabled. It's been a couple of hours and I can still install Netflix from Play Store, so I am confident I'm passing SafetyNet.

Anyone have any thoughts as to why SudoHide 1.28 that I install from EdXposed Manager 4.5.3 won't detect the Xposed framework? It is switched ON in the Modules section. I don't have this problem with 1.28.3 FYI. Maybe some setting or something I need to change?

Thanks!

FINAL EDIT:

But yes 1.28 works with App List Mode whereas 1.28.3 does not -- for me at least.

Figured out the SudoHide culprit... I enabled EdXposed's Speed Mode and that borked the framework. Minminguard also couldn't detect the framework. Once I updated EdXposed Manager to 4.5.4.0.1, I saw that the framework wasn't fully enabled even though modules still seem to function.

I cleared cache/dalvik cache and that seemed to undo the Speed Mode damage where the framework worked again. After some time passed, the framework again failed and I uninstalled EdXposed and reinstalled it but this time used Manager 4.5.3 instead of the latest version. Seems like version 4.5.4.0.1 was giving me problems as well.

[Mikanoshi]

I don't believe anyone who says original 1.28 is working with App List Mode :)
It loads settings like this:
https://github.com/SudoCode755/SudoHide/blob/master/app/src/main/java/com/sudocode/sudoHideModule/XposedMain.java#L41
And as mod hooks android framework all the shared prefs reload calls happen in a context of processes that retrieve package info. None of them are running with root privileges, and with app list mode enabled initZygote is also called for every starting process, but never in a zygote process, the only one running as root. So if you have restrictive SELinux it won't allow any of these calls to successfully read shared preferences. You all must be running with SELinux set to permissive using some Magisk module :)

My SudoHide 1.28.3 build does not reload preferences of the fly, only in initZygote, and to make that possible I had to add permission fix that makes shared prefs xml world readable:
https://github.com/Mikanoshi/SudoHide/blob/master/app/src/main/java/com/sudocode/sudohide/MainActivity.java#L117
In my build reload might actually work from other processes (even though it depends on the process) if I ever bother to add it of course :)

[drewcu]

SELinux ENFORCED and App List Mode ENABLED here...

In my case, 1.28 hides Youtube from the Play Store, whereas 1.28.3 does not.

Have you tried yourself or just going off assumptions?

[Mikanoshi]

Android version? Yeah, turns out original also had this permission fix)
Reload can still be unreliable, does it work when you hide an app from non-system app?
That's what happens if you try to read prefs file with 777 permissions from random process on Android 9 with enforcing SELinux:

2020-01-14 22:19:18.689 29169-29169/? W/XSharedPreferen: type=1400 audit(0.0:110373): avc: denied { search } for name="com.sudocode.sudohide" dev="sda21" ino=1381758 scontext=u:r:priv_app:s0:c512,c768 tcontext=u:object_r:app_data_file:s0:c2,c257,c512,c768 tclass=dir permissive=0

Google Play Market process with priv_app context cannot do it, original module does not work.

[drewcu]

LG V30 VS996 running stock Pie 9.0

With 1.28, I just successfully hid Sesame Shortcuts from Nova Launcher -- both non-system apps.

[Mikanoshi]

Don't know how that's possible, SELinux should not allow it, otherwise it will be useless, unless some relaxed rules were applied to it.
It certainly does not allow such thing on my Xiaomi Mi Mix 2S with Android 9 ROM.

[SoumyBhow]

Don't know how that's possible, SELinux should not allow it, otherwise it will be useless, unless some relaxed rules were applied to it.
It certainly does not allow such thing on my Xiaomi Mi Mix 2S with Android 9 ROM.

You're using the stock ROM? I don't mean to be rude or disrespectful, but I don't think it's fair to base things off of a Xiaomi ROM since their system is way too different. Chinese OEMs tend to jack up normal things in AOSP...

What's wrong with the original SudoHide working, anyways?

[Mikanoshi]

You're using the stock ROM?

Custom. Original SudoHide is not working unless I switch to permissive, it's enough for me to consider this unusable for my own build. Module makes one app read files owned by another, theoretically that should not work, that's what SELinux is for. Maybe EdXposed has SELinux rules for non-Xiaomi devices that allow that, don't know.

[SoumyBhow]

You're using the stock ROM?

Custom. Original SudoHide is not working unless I switch to permissive, it's enough for me to consider this unusable for my own build. Module makes one app read files owned by another, theoretically that should not work, that's what SELinux is for. Maybe EdXposed has SELinux rules for non-Xiaomi devices that allow that, don't know.

Now that you mention it, don't the newer canary builds of Edxposed use sepolicy patch or something like that? Could that be what you're talking about?

[Mikanoshi]

Ugh, I don't know anymore, they can't decide where to shove those rules - in EdXposed, in Magisk or in Magisk module :) Fact is that mod is not working on all devices and app list mode makes it very hard to fix this.

[Mikanoshi]

I found why my version of the module is not working, it is compiled with target SDK 28.
If you target Android 9 it will trigger additional SELinux rules that specifically prevent apps from reading world readable files of other apps, security my ass :)
https://developer.android.com/about/versions/pie/android-9.0-changes-28#per-app-selinux

EdXposed I'm currently using (0.4.5.5 4470 YAHFA) does not remove those rules.

[nritech]

Very happy with Taichi. Being 2 months and no issues whatsoever and safetynet.

[hsheidaryarad]

hi, tichi its support jasi patcher and lucky patcher frame work???

On Wed, 15 Jan 2020, 23:21 nritech, [e-mail] wrote:

Very happy with Taichi. Being 2 months and no issues whatsoever and
safetynet.

—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposed/issues/386?email_source=notifications&email_token=AMFV7C42Q4HP3WHB5B47I4TQ55SL3A5CNFSM4JJOWDLKYY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEJBS6KI#issuecomment-574828329,
or unsubscribe
https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AMFV7CY33UUFJWIGUTANOPDQ55SL3ANCNFSM4JJOWDLA
.

[drewcu]

Very happy with Taichi. Being 2 months and no issues whatsoever and safetynet.

I could never get Taichi to work with Gravitybox 9.0 - 9.1.3 (my main reason for Xposed)-- always got the framework not detected error, and eventually gave up. Have you had better success with Gravitybox?

[kinesight]

Yeah! Same bug here (but I've found workaround!)

Here:
Lineage OS 16 (Android 9)
Newest Official Magisk Canary:
20.2 (20102)
Manager 7.4.1 (255)
Manager Hidden
Newest EdXposed Manager v4.5.1
Newest Riru v19.5
Newest UNOFFICIAL EdXposed v0.4.6.0 beta (4471) SandHook (by Dark_Eyes_ at XDA Forum, to run with official Magisk)
Google Play Store v17.3.16

Lots of modules, including system wide XprivacyLua, Xposed Edge Pro,.....

SafetyNet completely broken in Magisk check. Both CTS and BasicIntegrity fail.

WORKAROUND: after turn on EdXposed Manager Black List feature and turn it on for Play Store, Play Services and Google Framework, SafetyNet becomes all green again! :) Try it!

Hope a fix. Thanks.

ISSUE

EdXposed now tripped Safetynet

EdXposed : Yahfa v0.4.6.1 (4497) Canary
Device : Samsung Galaxy A20(SM-A205F)
ROM : Android 9.0 OneUI Stock Rom

A couple of days back when 4497 was released It tripped Safetynet. I was told of a solution by which I had to enable the black list mode in EdXposed Manager and select Google Framework/Google Services and Google Play Store. After I had done this , I did a Safetynet check and all was perfect.

However the issue that I began having was that my apps ( from any launcher I that I used) had started lagging for about 1-2 seconds after I tapped on them to launch it. I have reverted my settings and to see if that the backlisting caused the lag and that was what had caused it.

I've tried Sandhook and Yahfa and received the same output.

[Mikanoshi]

However the issue that I began having was that my apps ( from any launcher I that I used) had started lagging for about 1-2 seconds after I tapped on them to launch it.

That's how this mode works, instead of initializing each mod on boot once it does this on launch of each process. If some mod (or their combination) results in noticeable performance hit, you will feel it every time you launch something.

[kinesight]

@Mikanoshi Oooooohhh😬😬😬😬 that makes sense. Thanks, how come my lag is so bad that no one else has it?

[Mikanoshi]

Depends on the active modules I guess.

[kinesight]

Anyway I can overcome this? Right now I have disabled the workaround and am using my phone with tripped Safetynet.

[Mikanoshi]

Try to enable it without any active mods, if it's still slow then it's EdXposed problem, if not then enable modules one by one until you find which causes slow down.

[drewcu]

I had a similar lag with Yahfa (all versions I tried), but not Sandhook which is super fast for me (though was less stable until recently).

[Mikanoshi]

SandHook will most likely crash some apps regularly on recent ROMs. Not a breaking bug, can rarely cause soft reboot if crash is in system process, but mostly it's just annoying :)

[nritech]

@drewcu No need for gravitybox as my rom itself got tons of tweaks way better and superior than gravitybox. I use taichi few modules and that serves my purpose. And thats why I was looking for edxposed but its now a crap at least for me.
Thankfully Taichi is ultra light and doesn't fuccks the system like edxposed and simply and quietly does its job. Kudos to the developer.

IMO Edxposed is crap, buggy, prone to safetynet issues and kills all the fun!

@hsheidaryarad lucky patcher is supported.

[devanteweary]

@nritech

I'm starting to believe you about EdXposed being buggy (more than normal).

I'm like 99% sure it's the reason my apps uninstall themselves after pretty much every reboot.
I rebooted twice today and both times I lost a random app. This has been going on for a couple of weeks.
Sometimes the apps are easy to replace, like ebay. Sometimes they are a pain, like Tiles. I have to reconfigure them all. One time I lost all my google settings and had to log into everything.

Just now I rebooted and upon restart, it asked me what would I like my default launcher to be. After I selected Nova (which I've used for years), whatever it is that lets you use the pulldown quick settings and other system tasks weren't working and I had to reboot. On reboot, I lost another app. This time it was Aquamail (which hopefully my backup settings will import).

Pretty sure I'm going to uninstall EdXposed and monitor it.

edit: I just had it uninstall two more apps.

[ayush7gl]

Having weird issue, SafetyNet keep failing but on opening edxposed manager SafetyNet passes. I gave autostart permission to edxposed manager and also disabled battery saving for this but same issue, Any solution for this.

[essare]

Detailed workaround:
1: open EdExposed installer
2: from Drawer Menu select: EdExp settings
3: Enable "Black/White List"
4: return to Drawer Menu and select Black/White List
5: Check: Google Play, Google Play services, and Google services framework
6: Reboot.
Now you should see green Safety Net with EdExposed properly working ☺️

[SoumyBhow]

I've enabled App List Mode and Pass SafetyNet in Edxp Manager. I also have the issue where if I go to Magisk Manager and check SafetyNet, it fails completely. However, if I clear MM from memory and try a couple of seconds later, it passes. Also, after I clear data of Google Play Services, Play Store and Arcore, I can install Netflix, but it disappears in a couple of minutes to hours and I have to clear data and reboot to bring it back (I don't even use Netflix but I've become obsessed with having it in my play store after seeing this thread...). If there's anything I need to provide to solve these problems, please let me know!

[obengsakti]

pass safetynet without blacklist playservice
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SROfotyG5Co

[reyqn]

That's interesting. Can you make a PR?

[alroy214]

@reyqn PR?

[reyqn]

@alroy214 Pull Request, basically sharing his code that seem to make safetynet pass without blacklisting playservice to edxposed's maintainers.

[alroy214]

@reyqn Okay got it, just didn't connect PR to pull request, sounds reasonable

[drewcu]

pass safetynet without blacklist playservice
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SROfotyG5Co

How can I test this Blacksoft version? Safetynet fails randomly for me and that's even with App List Mode and blocking GSF and GPS. Thanks!

[ayush7gl]

pass safetynet without blacklist playservice
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SROfotyG5Co

Where can i download these magisk module and xposed?

[rizanoalfaro]

@obengsakti link please :pray:

[obengsakti]

oke
very soon

[drewcu]

Uninstalled regular EdXposed and installed the Blacksoft version -- framework and core plus apk.
Enabled my modules and all seems fine except I'm failing Safetynet every time in Magisk (latest versions).
Even tried the App list mode / blocking GSF/GPS in original EdXposed Manager and still fail.
Must be some step I'm missing
Also have a lot of lag similar to my YAHFA experience.

Going back to Sandhook 0.4.5.1 as at least that passes Safetynet half the time.

[obengsakti]

Uninstalled regular EdXposed and installed the Blacksoft version -- framework and core plus apk.
Enabled my modules and all seems fine except I'm failing Safetynet every time in Magisk (latest versions).
Even tried the App list mode / blocking GSF/GPS in original EdXposed Manager and still fail.
Must be some step I'm missing
Also have a lot of lag similar to my YAHFA experience.

Going back to Sandhook 0.4.5.1 as at least that passes Safetynet half the time.

read the readme.txt

[drewcu]

read the readme.txt

Yes, I copied EXP.apk to system/app and rebooted. EXP gave the green light and the modules worked, but Safetynet failed every time I tried within Magisk. I tried Magisk Hiding GSF/GPS and unhiding them as well -- same failure.

[nritech]

Why still tail behind buggy Safetynet crapper EdXposed?
Why not simply try Taichi and get forever Safetynet Green and live free...

No complexity, no shity troubleshooting but just straightforward peace!

[MlgmXyysd]

Why still tail behind edxposed etc. Why not simply try Taichi and live freedom forever?

because TaiChi is a commercial framework, highly dangerous and have backdoor

[nritech]

Why still tail behind edxposed etc. Why not simply try Taichi and live freedom forever?

because TaiChi is a commercial application, highly dangerous and have backdoor

Well I didn't found any such sniffing....And what about edxposed? Whats the guarantee?

[MlgmXyysd]

Why still tail behind edxposed etc. Why not simply try Taichi and live freedom forever?

because TaiChi is a commercial application, highly dangerous and have backdoor

Well I didn't found any such sniffing....And what about edxposed? Whats the guarantee?

Open source is the best guarantee. For the system framework, if the source code cannot be provided, he must have a ghost in his mind

[Senliast]

Why still tail behind buggy Safetynet crapper EdXposed?
Why not simply try Taichi and get forever Safetynet Green and live free...

No complexity, no shity troubleshooting but just straightforward peace!

Because not all modules work on TaiChi. But by itself it is not bad.

[Senliast]

Why still tail behind edxposed etc. Why not simply try Taichi and live freedom forever?

because TaiChi is a commercial framework, highly dangerous and have backdoor

Closed source doesn't mean backdoor necessary. You don't know if it has backdoor, you only guess. Closed source, for example, for protection against Google and safety net. BTW, TaiChi is more stable on Android 10 then EdXposed, cos the devs of EdXposed didn't updated it since long time. One big disadvantage of TaiChi is small amount of modules supported.

[MlgmXyysd]

@Senliast No, I found a privilege escalation during decompilation, and I found a very wrong behavior in eula. For details, please refer to the xda post I mentioned earlier.

[hoistedPetard]

Why still tail behind edxposed etc. Why not simply try Taichi and live freedom forever?

because TaiChi is a commercial framework, highly dangerous and have backdoor

Closed source doesn't mean backdoor necessary. You don't know if it has backdoor, you only guess. Closed source, for example, for protection against Google and safety net. BTW, TaiChi is more stable on Android 10 then EdXposed, cos the devs of EdXposed didn't updated it since long time. One big disadvantage of TaiChi is small amount of modules supported.

By your logic, it is not a problem to get shot by a gun, because there is no guarantee of death. It is possible that the bullet might bounce off. But most people refer to mitigate risks.

The biggest disadvantage is still that it is closed source and uses obfuscated code. It is hiding something, and we have only the sketchy author's promises that it is clean. And a few people including the author make posts in poor, broken English trying to con users into trying it, for "some" reason.

Taichi might be clean, and bullets might bounce off. But both are too risky to try.

"If it quacks like a duck..."

[MlgmXyysd]

@hoistedPetard Yes, only his author says he is "clean", but no one can guarantee it except the code, because the device behavior is determined by the code.

[hoistedPetard]

@hoistedPetard Yes, only his author says he is "clean", but no one can guarantee it except the code, because the device behavior is determined by the code.

Exactly

[nritech]

So what if we install Taichi in non-root mode?

Also, whats the current edxposed foolproof method to pass safetynet for good?

Last time on multiple occasions Edxposed caused severe battery drain on my device.

[Senliast]

So what if we install Taichi in non-root mode?

Also, whats the current edxposed foolproof method to pass safetynet for good?

Last time on multiple occasions Edxposed caused severe battery drain on my device.

You can pass SafetyNet with EdXposed by going into EdXposed manager settings, then activating App list mode and pass SafetyNet option and rebooting.

[MlgmXyysd]

@nritech I am afraid that it is not a good solution under non-root. I encountered several people using TaiChi without root(in a xposed module discuss group). As a result, user app data was corrupted.

In the end, the problem was located on TaiChi, and even the uninstallation did not work. The only solution was to restore the factory settings.

[howyay]

Enough detour on Taichi, we should honestly focus on problems at hand.

[ThePotato97]

Why still tail behind buggy Safetynet crapper EdXposed?
Why not simply try Taichi and get forever Safetynet Green and live free...

No complexity, no shity troubleshooting but just straightforward peace!

Just deleted Taichi thanks to this shady comment.

[shmykelsa]

All right, I think this is going FAR BEYOND ACCEPTABLE.

The issue are made so that the developer(s) are aware of a bug/issue/possible enhancement with the own software.

People that are here to give alternatives claiming that they work better, that they have no bugs, that that software makes life free, can get out of here, as far as I'm concerned.

I'm pretty sure @ElderDrivers is working on a solution on this, and I think he/she/they are pretty aware of the issue by now.

What you can do to help the developers? Give them freaking infos about the configuration and the issue, not give alternatives to people round here.

[hoistedPetard]

This might not help anyone because most people here are probably wanting to use GPay and other financial apps that detect root, but for posterity, I have ONLY been trying to get Netflix working, and I just did this:

Install Storage Redirect and xPrivacylua and restrict Netflix from everything in both, then install the Netflix app from Aurora Store. I fail both Safetynet checks in Magisk, but Netflix works well. No db scripts, no special modules, no blacklists, whitelists, app mode or anything, just Magisk Hide and Hide Magisk Manager both enabled.

I am stoked that this works.

Running LineageOS 16 on a Moto G7, all the latest stable releases of Magisk and EdXposed.

[SoumyBhow]

Does widevine affect whether or not Netflix is in the play store? I did a bit of research and I found out that widevine changes from L1 to L3 when unlocking the bootloader of my device (OnePlus 7 Pro).

[Senliast]

This might not help anyone because most people here are probably wanting to use GPay and other financial apps that detect root, but for posterity, I have ONLY been trying to get Netflix working, and I just did this:

Install Storage Redirect and xPrivacylua and restrict Netflix from everything in both, then install the Netflix app from Aurora Store. I fail both Safetynet checks in Magisk, but Netflix works well. No db scripts, no special modules, no blacklists, whitelists, app mode or anything, just Magisk Hide and Hide Magisk Manager both enabled.

I am stoked that this works.

Running LineageOS 16 on a Moto G7, all the latest stable releases of Magisk and EdXposed.

Netflix itself also doesnt check SafetyNet, it only gets hidden on Gay Store, if you install Netflix without these all restrictions, it will works aswell.

[heatl0rd]

I'm passing safety net Check in magisk but in googlepay I'm getting the below error.

https://photos.app.goo.gl/8ss6EBYvmwJtpS9o8

EdXposed_Verbose_20200229_111305.log

[GorvGoyl]

a new version of edxposed just got released 0.4.6. does it pass the safetynet now?

[ayush7gl]

New version 0.4.6.1 Yahfa varient seems to passing the SafetyNet.

[rizanoalfaro]

just use edxposed mod . auto green

[rizanoalfaro]

i use blacksoft xposed with lineage os 16 and get perfect results

[rizanoalfaro]

[Guddu4]

i use blacksoft xposed with lineage os 16 and get perfect results

can you please share the link for blacksoft xposed....

[etmatrix]

I tested 0.4.6.1 Yahfa on Lg G5 Android 8.0 stock image, the safetynet pass with test application as magisk and others, but with real application no.
All tested app are hided with magisk.

[Senliast]

SafetyNet still randomly fail

[StormPooper]

Passes for me without any modules enabled, fails as soon as I enable any. Tried both YAFHA and Sandhook with no difference, also did a clean install of Edxposed Manager since I was being told it was enabled but not active.

[Senliast]

Passes for me without any modules enabled, fails as soon as I enable any. Tried both YAFHA and Sandhook with no difference, also did a clean install of Edxposed Manager since I was being told it was enabled but not active.

Tried to activate app list mode and SafetyNet pass option in the settings? It works in most cases, but sometimes on SafetyNet request fails even if this active... And it will not be fixed since months...

[StormPooper]

Tried to activate app list mode and SafetyNet pass option in the settings?

Yup, tried most things in this thread before and after this update, no difference.

[Senliast]

I thought, SafetyNet still fails sometimes, but no, I checked right now, on the latest build now it doesn't pass at all, every time it fails. App list mode and SafetyNet pass option enabled and rebooted.

[srccrow]

Add PlayStore to blacklist, also... SafetyNet attest seems to fail validation lately, tried with another app "Root Checker Pro" and from inside Magisk both pass.

[dotprofile]

Somehow I am passing with Google apps hooked and no extra modules that modify the state of safety net.

I'm on a OnePlus 6 with Evo-X rom, latest Edxposed and using xprivacylua. I'm pretty puzzled as to why it's working. I've been on this rom for a few days now and rebooted many times and it still passes.

Edit: I was on another rom and dirty flashed to the one I am on (which isn't recommend, I also later clean flashed) and ended up passing safety net. The dirty flash alone made me pass, without any other changes.

Is there anything I could provide for someone to analyze as to why it's working now?

[refi64]

I believe I've had better luck with it not randomly failing after around 2
days or so since I disabled battery optimization on EdXposed Manager,
although it could just be coincidence. Will check in with more results
eventually, but for now maybe it's something worth trying.

On Tue, Mar 3, 2020, 7:01 PM dotprofile [e-mail] wrote:

Somehow I am passing with Google apps hooked and no extra modules that
modify the state of safety net.

I'm on a OnePlus 6 with Evo-X rom, latest Edxposed and using xprivacylua.
I'm pretty puzzled as to why it's working. I've been on this rom for a few
days now and rebooted many times and it still passes.

—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposed/issues/386?email_source=notifications&email_token=AAM4YSLGZ3ODWNEDQSN5YPLRFWR5LA5CNFSM4JJOWDLKYY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOENVYYIQ#issuecomment-594250786,
or unsubscribe
https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAM4YSML3KJ2EMQ6RJWH6XTRFWR5LANCNFSM4JJOWDLA
.

[kinesight]

I just came across HiddenCore Module today and after I rebooted, everything was green. No Lag or Chrome Issues. Is this thing FOR REAL?

Samsung Galaxy A20 (SM-A205F)
Android 9.0 ( OneUI 1.1)

https://repo.xposed.info/module/com.cofface.ivader

[StormPooper]

HiddenCore worked for me for most of yesterday after your suggestion, but I woke up this morning to Google Pay deciding it was no longer compatible, so I've had to turn it off again.

[Guddu4]

hidden core module is working for me as well......
any one has link for blacksoft exposed installer?

[Ashesh3]

@rizanoalfaro Can you provide us links for Blacksoft Edexposed? seems like its no longer available on the internet. Thanks

[nritech]

Ok so I had no issues whatsoever since 3-4 months now and last week updated all my apps and then too was no issues but today suddenly ctsprofile:false WTF?

Phone: Redmi Note 7 Pro
Magisk: Still on v19.4

When I entered Magisk manager, it prompted me for this:

I had no option to continue...but seems I shouldn't had else MagiskHide Props Config would had worked... just my thoughts though...

_I was using Safetynetpatch and it was working absolutely fine._

So today....

• Uninstalled safetynet patch...rebooted
• Installed latest MagiskHide Props Config ..rebooted
• Fired terminal and installed fingerprint of Redmi note 8.. reboot..same result... ctsprofile:false
• Installed another fingerprint of Pixel 4.. reboot..same result... ctsprofile:false

_What the hell had gone wrong can someone tell me?_

Banking apps now not accessible even though they weren't updated.

In Magisk hide, all Google stuff is ticked.

Do I need to do anything more>?

[MlgmXyysd]

@nritech Google's new bug, we can do NOTHING.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/pixel-4-xl/help/march-update-ctsprofile-false-clean-t4062987
https://forum.xda-developers.com/pixel-3-xl/how-to/ctsprofile-false-march-firmware-t4063285

[nritech]

@nritech Google's new bug, we can do NOTHING.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/pixel-4-xl/help/march-update-ctsprofile-false-clean-t4062987
https://forum.xda-developers.com/pixel-3-xl/how-to/ctsprofile-false-march-firmware-t4063285

So did any update triggered it? I mean the updates which I did last week?

[MlgmXyysd]

@nritech I don't know, at least I can pass (I haven't made any updates)

OnePlus 7T Pro

[nritech]

@nritech I don't know, at least I can pass (I haven't made any updates)

OnePlus 7T Pro

I manually uninstalled all google variant updates still its failing...

Seems have to clean flash old rom and check..but this painful activity wastes my few days to config whole device and what not...

Praying for some hack by our crack/hack community..

[MlgmXyysd]

@nritech I don't know, at least I can pass (I haven't made any updates)
OnePlus 7T Pro

I unsinattled all google varinat updates still its fialing...

It's not EdXposed related bug, check threads in XDA will help you.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=81955393&postcount=2

[nritech]

I have unrooted my phone aka removed magisk completely but seems safetynet check fails on root checking apps.

Seems this time google fked it very hard this time....
Can Unlock bootloader also trigger safetynet check?

All apps working fine except Ola cab app. It keeps saying since this week:

FAILURE! SORRY SOMETHING WENT WRONG PLEASE TRY AGAIN.

or

THE OLA APP IS NOT AVAILABLE FOR USE ON THIS DEVICE.

Its a sheer shame that Gpay and banking apps are working without issues and this Ola apps refuses to. I tried clear data, uninstall reboot bla bla and even tried Dec 2019 version but same issues.

Can someone comment on some help here....

[MlgmXyysd]

I have unrooted my phone aka removed magisk completely but seems safetynet check fails on root checking apps.

Seems this time google fked it very hard this time....
Can Unlock bootloader also trigger safetynet check?

All apps working fine except Ola cab app. It keeps saying since this week:

FAILURE! SORRY SOMETHING WENT WRONG PLEASE TRY AGAIN.

or

THE OLA APP IS NOT AVAILABLE FOR USE ON THIS DEVICE.

Its a sheer shame that Gpay and banking apps are working without issues and this Ola apps refuses to. I tried clear data, uninstall reboot bla bla and even tried Dec 2019 version but same issues.

Can someone comment on some help here....

According to @topjohnwu 's Twitter, it may no longer be possible to pass SafetyNet verification

https://twitter.com/topjohnwu/status/1237656703929180160?s=19

Google done it boys, SafetyNet Pass is no more

[nritech]

I have unrooted my phone aka removed magisk completely but seems safetynet check fails on root checking apps.
Seems this time google fked it very hard this time....
Can Unlock bootloader also trigger safetynet check?
All apps working fine except Ola cab app. It keeps saying since this week:
FAILURE! SORRY SOMETHING WENT WRONG PLEASE TRY AGAIN.
or
THE OLA APP IS NOT AVAILABLE FOR USE ON THIS DEVICE.
Its a sheer shame that Gpay and banking apps are working without issues and this Ola apps refuses to. I tried clear data, uninstall reboot bla bla and even tried Dec 2019 version but same issues.
Can someone comment on some help here....

According to @topjohnwu 's Twitter, it may no longer be possible to pass SafetyNet verification

https://twitter.com/topjohnwu/status/1237656703929180160?s=19

Google done it boys, SafetyNet Pass is no more
Already read the news..

I think we can still use stock roms right?
Thats what I asked, does unlocking bootloader trigger safetynet?
If no then we dont have to worry.

If Yes, then the world is back to stock rom days it seems....forums dead and just basic discussions around.

[MlgmXyysd]

@nritech I dont know...
As far as I guess, unlocking the bootloader will trigger SafetyNet, even if the device is “relocked”.

But we seem to only be able to switch between "unlocked" and "relock", we cannot switch to the "lock" state

[nritech]

@nritech I dont know...
As far as I guess, unlocking the bootloader will trigger SafetyNet, even if the device is “relocked”.

But we seem to only be able to switch between "unlocked" and "relock", we cannot switch to the "lock" state

Ok. So if we reflash a stock clean image with a locked bootloader the phone should work as before right ?

[MlgmXyysd]

@nritech just say NO

Phone state is "locked" before you bought.

you run "fastboot flashing/oem unlock" will change state to "unlocked"

even you run "fastboot flashing/oem relock", change state to "relocked"

and you may unable change state to "locked"(idk 9008)

[dotprofile]

https://twitter.com/topjohnwu/status/1237656704537395201
This explains why I'm still passing. Google done it.

[nritech]

@nritech just say NO

Phone state is "locked" before you bought.

you run "fastboot flashing/oem unlock" will change state to "unlocked"

even you run "fastboot flashing/oem relock", change state to "relocked"

and you may unable change state to "locked"(idk 9008)

I will reflash stock rom once I go home this weekend and check the results and post here.. Else my phone is still under warranty so will probably give back to Xiaomi for an upgrade..
I have ZERO concerns except now this Ola cab app refuses to work... This is pissing me off and just for this one app I will have to altogether go back to stock just to verify integrity.

[nritech]

An Update: Someone flashed stock rom with BL lock and all seems good, everything is passing.

[MlgmXyysd]

Say goodbye to SafetyNet, then close this issue.

https://t.me/EdXposed/71

[Ashesh3]

Rip

[nritech]

A way will be found, patience is all whats required...

[nritech]

Well well...as I said... read this... Safetynet is now passing for all where it failed last week....
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/mod-magisk-v1-universal-systemless-t3432382/page3883

[MlgmXyysd]

@nritech Please be thankful. This is Google's mercy. It can still be blocked at any time

[nritech]

@nritech Please be thankful. This is Google's mercy. It can still be blocked at any time

It can also be that during the initial phase it blocked everything and now after all got settled/implemented properly all is good. Yes its google so we cant be sure how long this may work so lets see...
It may also happen they are implementing some changes hence ftw allowed all devices and again in this week or so it will go back to square one!

[kevin01523]

Manager aplist mode doesnt work anymore with riru edxposed if the manager has some new magiskhide features it migh work
If riru edxposed is active even without modules enabled safetynet is now tripped

[google-eye]

has been shutdown

[obengsakti]

has been shutdown

crazy!!! all red now! reeeeeddddd

[obengsakti]

@solohsu @MlgmXyysd

[refi64]

https://twitter.com/topjohnwu/status/1245956080779198464

On Sun, Apr 5, 2020, 11:16 PM obengsakti [e-mail] wrote:

@solohsu https://github.com/solohsu @MlgmXyysd
https://github.com/MlgmXyysd

—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposed/issues/386#issuecomment-609555733,
or unsubscribe
https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAM4YSN4RZKJOIWS3N7WKHDRLFJSHANCNFSM4JJOWDLA
.

[nritech]

has been shutdown

crazy!!! all red now! reeeeeddddd

all GREEN for me!

[obengsakti]

has been shutdown

crazy!!! all red now! reeeeeddddd

all GREEN for me!

how

[obengsakti]

yes yes fix 100%

[obengsakti]

has been shutdown

ez

[Ashesh3]

yes yes fix 100%

How?

[andrewcch1226]

@Ashesh3 install canary build can fix the safety problem :)

[otmaxxx]

@Ashesh3 install canary build can fix the safety problem :)

Thank god something useful

[kevin01523]

Got tripped again today even w ver 5.0

[Ashesh3]

Got tripped again today even w ver 5.0

same, again

[TuRDMaN]

I somehow had it working for a bit today with everything enabled, but now I can't pass SafetyNet unless I disable Riru Core (it's not enough to just disable EdXposed)

[nritech]

All is working good for me but decided to not use root anymore on phone. But I still use root apps on Taichi

[iamehsangh]

i added Store,Framework,Services to Blacklist, Still all false, Only way is HiddenCore Module in Xposed...
i dont know why i getting some lags with this module!!

[blackcatdev]

There's new version of Riru Core in Magisk that isn't triggering SafetyNet.

[TuRDMaN]

There's new version of Riru Core in Magisk that isn't triggering SafetyNet.

I installed Riru Core v21.1, and I am passing SafetyNet now. I saw there is a new Canary Riru EdXposed module (v0.5.0.0 4548), so I installed that.... and I am getting "EdXposed Framework is installed, but not active." I tried to reverting to the previous Canary version, but get the same error.

So I'm guessing we have to wait for a new EdXposed update that works with Riru Core v21.1?

Edit: Reinstalling EdXposed Manager got everything working again

[MikePerreman]

Hello all, just wanted to add my 2c:
These modules let me install vanced (root) and pass safteynet with edxpoded running. If it's worth anything, I'm running MSM Xtended (Android 10) on a OnePlus5t

[JasonKhew96]

Notes:

1. Make sure your device passed safetynet before installing Magisk.
2. Turn on magisk hide after installing Magisk.
3. If your device can only pass _basicIntegrity_, get _Magiskhide Props Config_ and get a new fingerprint.
4. Install _Riru - Core_ v21.1 or later version, _Riru - EdXposed (4546)_ and latest _EdXposed Manager_
5. Turn on _Applist / Black/Whitelist mode_ and passed safetynet switch, reboot.
6. Check safetynet in Magisk Manager (check multiple time, it's buggy), if all red, clear _gsf_ data (will break all fcm/gcm notifications).

FFS, don't use _HiddenCore_ module, it fakes the response from safetynet response only, and it only works on magisk manager(?)

[Nowaker]

clear gsf data

What's gsf and how do I clear its data?

[kotori2]

@Nowaker Google Service Framework

[Nowaker]

Cool, and how to clear its data?

[Nowaker]

I've found something. On OnePlus 6: Settings > Apps > See all $number apps > ... > Show System > Google Services Framework > Storage & cache > Clear cache and Clear storage.

I've followed all steps, except (3): If your device can only pass basicIntegrity, get Magiskhide Props Config and get a new fingerprint. After installing Riru Core and EdXposed, my device passes neither of the checks: ctsProfile: false, basicIntegrity: false. In this case, what should I do?

[EkriirkE]

I'd like to add that while clearing Play Services restores safety net, so does simply rebooting and you don't lose your Google Pay cards. Even the Soft Reboot restores it. Hidden Core always shows green, and app updates will randomly trip it. But I just soft reboot, verity with safety check in magisk, and Google Pay works again (and other things like pokemon go). Sometimes you need to wait a couple minutes and click "check Phone" a few times before Pay says the phone is valid and no root is detectd

[nritech]

Has anyone tried new magisk? Crap ui and drains battery

[BobbyWibowo]

After installing Riru Core and EdXposed, my device passes neither of the checks: ctsProfile: false, basicIntegrity: false. In this case, what should I do?

Did you have any progress with this, mate?

My bad, forgot to enable App List mode in EdXposed to blacklist GSF. After clearing data & cache of GSF, Play Services and Play Store, then rebooting, everything worked as they should.

[gusarov]

Hi guys, finally this worked for me! The key point was - an upgrade to Canary version of Riru - EdExposed.
Today latest official version is 0.4.6.2 (4529) and Safety Net is red no matter what I'm doing.
For those who struggling: All you need to do is:
1) Open EdExposed Manager, Canary Tab: Download latest here (today it is 4564) to your Downloads folder.
2) Open Magisk Manager, Modules, "Install From Storage", and select the ZIP you just donloaded
Install & reboot.

[ayush5harma]

Hi guys, finally this worked for me! The key point was - an upgrade to Canary version of Riru - EdExposed.
Today latest official version is 0.4.6.2 (4529) and Safety Net is red no matter what I'm doing.
For those who struggling: All you need to do is:

1. Open EdExposed Manager, Canary Tab: Download latest here (today it is 4564) to your Downloads folder.
2. Open Magisk Manager, Modules, "Install From Storage", and select the ZIP you just donloaded
   Install & reboot.

One shouldn't be using edxposed build from android_r branch on android q, it also leads to safetynet issue.The version 0.4.6.4 (4563) is the latest build for those in android Q and can be downloaded from :(https://ci.appveyor.com/project/ElderDrivers/edxposed/builds/35441002/artifacts)

You can always check for these builds from AppVeyor build history and download them from the artifacts tab
(https://ci.appveyor.com/project/ElderDrivers/edxposed/history)

[Raslin777]

Safetynet tripped again. Using v0.5.0.6 sandhook, Edxposed Hide, Edxposed manager v4.6.0pre and Magisk 20.4, Magisk Hide, Magiskhide props 5.3.6, Riru core v21.3. Just started yesterday didn't change anything on phone. Didn't have any issues before that passing safetynet. If I disable Edxposed in Magisk it passes again.

[robbyoconnor]

This is going to be a game of cat and mouse. It will fail. The tricks on
this issue will likely work.

On 10/29/20 8:53 PM, Raslin777 wrote:
>

Safetynet tripped again. Using v0.5.0.6 sandhook, Edxposed Hide,
Edxposed manager v4.6.0pre and Magisk 20.4, Magisk Hide, Magiskhide
props 5.3.6, Riru core v21.3. Just started yesterday didn't change
anything on phone. Didn't have any issues before that.

—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposed/issues/386#issuecomment-719105598,
or unsubscribe
https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAAFUME46HBWSYSBWBTK3VLSNIE67ANCNFSM4JJOWDLA.

[shenzhigang]

Is it necessary to care about SafetyNet in China, when SafetyNet depends on GMS which is not available in China?

[google-mirror]

Is it necessary to care about SafetyNet in China, when SafetyNet depends on GMS which is not available in China?

Huawei's HMS

[Raslin777]

decodedJWTPayload json:{"nonce":"1jV/tfIHKP8iByQ3Bfz2jetTu2QY6mWUgtt7p3JvRaA=","timestampMs":1604365258086,"ctsProfileMatch":false,"apkCertificateDigestSha256":[],"basicIntegrity":false,"advice":"RESTORE_TO_FACTORY_ROM","evaluationType":"BASIC"}

[Raslin777]

I thought basic always passes. It's hardware backed that fails
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHideSafetyNet

[lulujyc]

Confirmed that SafetyNet is tripped by EdXposed 4564 on Magisk 21.0. Disable EdXposed & SafetyNet check will pass. Device is OnePlus 8 Pro on OxygenOS 11.

[ondrejdolezal93]

Hello, is there any way to pass safetynet these days with xposed modules enabled?

[google-mirror]

Hello, is there any way to pass safetynet these days with xposed modules enabled?

No way.

[Raslin777]

But it's not for me

[ayush5harma]

Hello, is there any way to pass safetynet these days with xposed modules enabled?

enable riru hide( by creating empty enable_hide file at /data/adb/riru/ ) and then use applist mode in edxposed manager and blacklist playstore ,playservices ,carrier services,and google service framework

[EkriirkE]

enable riru hide( by creating empty enable_hide file at /data/adb/riru/ ) and then use applist mode in edxposed manager and blacklist playstore ,playservices ,carrier services,and google service framework

This worked, but why is it a "hidden" setting?

[ayush5harma]

enable riru hide( by creating empty enable_hide file at /data/adb/riru/ ) and then use applist mode in edxposed manager and blacklist playstore ,playservices ,carrier services,and google service framework

This worked, but why is it a "hidden" setting?

hide can be toggled by individual modules (disabled by default).It leaves it to the module since this commit so its edxposed that should toggle riru hide on when applist mode is used.

Anyways it will only make safetynet pass for those whose safetynet started failing after enabling modules in edxposed which makes use of riru , but for those, whose safetynet always failed since rooting, this won't work either.

In short it's like for those whom it will work, can check out by trying to enable it by creating empty enable_hide file at /data/adb/riru/

[kotori2]

Nah. EdXposed does enable hide by default, but enable_hide is a global
switch, so you should create that file so that hide can work.

Ayush Sharma [e-mail] 于 2020年12月4日周五 16:32写道：

enable riru hide( by creating empty enable_hide file at /data/adb/riru/ )
and then use applist mode in edxposed manager and blacklist playstore
,playservices ,carrier services,and google service framework

This worked, but why is it a "hidden" setting?

hide can be toggled by individual modules (disabled by default)
https://github.com/RikkaApps/Riru/commit/dd993324e9d6ce3934cf710dd8544312fa8068ff.It
leaves it to the module since this commit so its Edxposed that should
toggle riru hide on by itself when applist mode is used.

But anyways it will only make safetynet pass for those whose safetynet
started failing after enabling modules in edxposed which makes use of riru
, but for those, whose safetynet always failed since rooting, this won't
work either.The magisk devs also disabled magisk hide by default in the
manager because it doesn't work for all these days.
In short it's like For those whom it will work, can check out by trying to
enable it.

—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposed/issues/386#issuecomment-738643309,
or unsubscribe
https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AEGYNSOZNKRIHZJVXZIEI63STCNAFANCNFSM4JJOWDLA
.