Dokuwiki: User self-registration is gone once plugin is installed

[pczekalski]

I'm using authad plugin along with authchained (it includes authad and authplain, to let me inject non-ad users of Dokuwiki).
Authad by design disables self-registration, however, in this case, it is reasonable to keep self-registration enabled.

How to re-enable it back still having authad running? I cannot see any option in the config files to force-enable it back.

Regards,

P

[phy25]

This is a question more suitable for the plugin authchained. Could you open an issue there instead?

[pczekalski]

Sure about it?
Please read the authad documentation: "_Also self registration by users is disabled by the authAD plugin._" (source: https://www.dokuwiki.org/plugin:authad)

I believe authchained has nothing to do here.

Please reopen...

[splitbrain]

Nope. AuthAD works as intended. When AuthChained allows for multiple auth backends it has to care about how to "merge" capabilities.

[pczekalski]

Thanks for the reply, however cannot agree.

Please consider the example:

1. authad, authplain enabled and authchained enabled = no local registration possible (wrong):
   

1. authad disabled, authplain enabled and authchained enabled = local registration possible (right):
   

Please reopen...

[Klap-in]

The authad and the authplain give both a signal yes/no whether it supports local registration. If you use them separately I understand that you see that these signals are recognized by the authchained plugin as well.

However, it appears that the authchained does not see (yet/anymore) that in this case one plugin says 'yes' and the other say 'no'. So in my opinion the first logic step is that the mechanism in authchained that checks these yes/no's have to be verified. Probably there something is not handled as expected.

[phy25]

And please create a new issue in authchained. I would say I don't see any reason to reopen this unless you can point out which code in DokuWiki core is causing the issue.

[pczekalski]

And please create a new issue in authchained. I would say I don't see any reason to reopen this unless you can point out which code in DokuWiki core is causing the issue.

Submitted in authchained. Thank you for your support.