Docker: PHP memory limit to 128 ?

[bitdegree67]

Hello, i'm using the latest image (with nextcloud 14)
and when i run any php occ command. i get this message
The current PHP memory limit is below the recommended value of 512MB.
i haven't touch the image. it's the official image from docker hub vanilla (with clean installation to mariadb)

[bitdegree67]

It's a good idea to PR this ?
RUN echo 'memory_limit = 512M' >> /usr/local/etc/php/conf.d/docker-php-memlimit.ini;
in Dockerfile of NC14 ?

[J0WI]

This is already set in .htaccess and .user.ini. Have you modified them?
You can also mount a custom config into /usr/local/etc/php.

[xXZaretXx]

Hello,
i have the same problem ,
the php limit is to 128 (php -i | grep memory_limit)
the values in .htacess and user.ini are set to 512

[bitdegree67]

@J0WI No, as i said. i've just run
docker run nextcloud
and then in this new nextcloud run "php occ" then i get the message of warning 128MB

[xXZaretXx]

@bitdegree67
You can change it with
echo 'memory_limit = 512M' >> /usr/local/etc/php/conf.d/docker-php-memlimit.ini;
inside the docker container
but i think its temporary and hacky

[bitdegree67]

@xXZaretXx I myself proposed this solution

[xXZaretXx]

@bitdegree67 ups yes you are right , i'm blind

[ixinshang]

Hello,
i have the same problem ,someone who can slove it. thanks.

[J0WI]

Thanks for providing the details. I can now reproduce the issue.
@tilosp since this has been added in https://github.com/nextcloud/server/pull/10539 (NC 14), should we change the defaults for the container?

[bitdegree67]

The question is why .htaccess isn't used by "php occ"

[J0WI]

Because it's the cli and not apache

[bitdegree67]

Alright! so it's dsn't a problem for nextcloud, only for occ

[cynecx]

@bitdegree67 It is apparently still an issue with the php-fpm variant. My current solution is to have my own derived Dockerfile which simply increases the mem limit, but I think this should really be included in upstream (php-fpm and the alpine alt).

Edit: I've just realized that the memory-limit configuration is also present in .user.ini, but somehow nextcloud was still complaining.

[J0WI]

There are two different checks in NextCloud:

• One is in the setting page, served through Apache or PHP-FPM and using .htaccess or .user.ini
• Another one is in the occ cli util (since NextCloud 14), which uses PHP defaults

You can always mount a custom my-config.ini file, that contains e.g. memory_limit = 512M, into /usr/local/etc/php/conf.d/.
I've created #460 to ship this setting by default.

[githubworkwork]

pora

Thank you