Containers-roadmap: [Fargate, ECS] [CloudFormation]: Support for tags in CloudFormation

Created on 7 Jan 2019  ·  17Comments  ·  Source: aws/containers-roadmap

Tell us about your request
Support for tagging resources from CloudFormation

Which service(s) is this request for?
Fargate, ECS

Tell us about the problem you're trying to solve. What are you trying to do, and why is it hard?
Currently there is no support for adding tags to things like AWS::ECS::Cluster and AWS::ECS::TaskDefinition in CloudWatch.

Are you currently working around this issue?
Adding the tags manually after CFN has created the stack.

ECS Fargate Proposed

Most helpful comment

Hi everyone, I want to assure you that this feature is actively in development and really is "coming soon". We will update this issue once it is released.

All 17 comments

@iconara AWS::ECS::Service is also on the list of resources that cannot be tagged using CloudFormation. I really hope they get this in soon as we depend on tagging for our ECS cost analysis using CloudCheckr.

What about EKS?

Hi @abby-fuller. You've added this to Coming Soon section on January 10th. I understand that this is on Cloudfromation team's plate, but I was wondering if you have any inside scoop on how soon we can expect this functionality. Thanks in advance!

Can you really call this coming soon if it wasn't delivered in 4 months?

@radifalco mere months is radically fast for CF time :smile: E.g. tags support for EIPs was added to EC2 in 2017, and AFAIK we are still waiting for CF support.

The fact that we need to spend more money (lambdas to tag) to figure how much money our ECS clusters are spending is so sad. I just hope that “coming soon” is not in à la Duke Nukem style (coming soon... when it’s done). :)

A suggestion to AWS:

It would be nice to release features with CloudFormation support first since your most advanced users use this heavily. or atleast have support for it a few weeks or at max a month after the feature is released. Or some how make CloudFormation opensource.

Thank You.

Every CFN team member out there...ever 🤣

Hello,
We are a big AWS customer heavily relying on tagging and ECS. Can we have an estimation when this feature will be made available ?
Thanks,

Hi everyone, I want to assure you that this feature is actively in development and really is "coming soon". We will update this issue once it is released.

Thanks @coultn! Will be very handy. I like to drop AWS::EC2::EIP into any missing CFN Tags conversation, in the hope that it too, will one day be 'coming soon'. 😄

+1

Any chance for an update on this issue?

AWS::ECR::Repository is also missing CloudFormation tagging support, would that be covered by the current feature development work or should a separate issue be opened?

AWS::ECR::Repository is also missing CloudFormation tagging support, would that be covered by the current feature development work or should a separate issue be opened?

@trav-c yes, tagging for ECR launched also: https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AWSCloudFormation/latest/UserGuide/aws-resource-ecr-repository.html

Thanks @coultn it does appear to have been missed in the release notes though.

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings