Bookmarks: Feature request add Comments to Bookmarks

[skoelzow]

Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe.
My fellow students and I share links to their YouTube clips taken from classes of our teacher.

The clips are shared as read only. Therefore other users can only click on them to open the link. In order to discuss the clips contents all users should be able to add comments.

Describe the solution you'd like
We know already the comments system used when we share files. Exactly the same look and feel would be great for bookmarks.

Describe alternatives you've considered
One could create one text file containing url, image and description for each link and then share it. But using bookmarks app would be a far more elegant and user friendly solution.

Additional context
The Website is still in beta testing with few users only. We are a community of hundreds of students and there are hundreds of clips. Using nextcloud with the bookmarks app seems to be the perfect combination for such a platform.

Many thanks for considering,
Stephan

[Spartachetto]

I am just trying to offer some suggestions, but maybe you could consider some other possibilities offered by Nextcloud:

• a Talk conversation in which the students share the bookmarks. I seem to remember that a functionality to grab all the links in a chat and trasform them in bookmarks exists or is planned...
• a project which includes the shared bookmarks and chat or text files....
• a markdown file that cites the bookmarks (@marcelklehr is this possible?)

[skoelzow]

Thanks @Spartachetto it is a good Idea to add a bookmark to a project. Unfortunateley this function is not implemented yet.
For me the beauty lies in the presentation of youtube bookmarks with their snapshot. Otherwise I could simply use the files_linkeditor app.

[AntoineD-dot-fr]

I know this is not the original function of this app.
But the ability to post comments would be very nice so that users from the same instance can discuss the shared content in a link.
A bit like on a forum or social network.

It could be usefull to provide additional facts for teaching or debunking

[kywan]

I would be strongly interested in this feature too. Being able to add a comment and/or feedback would be a real plus