Bloc: Do I need to create 2 Widgets? (Login example)

[joaogalli]

Hi, I am following the Login example, and noticed that I need to have the LoginPage and the LoginForm widgets for bloc to work.
Of course I tried to do both on the same Widget (LoginPage), but the BlocListener doesn't work.

Is there a way, or the example is the only right way?

[felangel]

Hi @joaogalli 👋
Thanks for opening an issue!

Are you able to share a link to a sample app which illustrates the problem you’re having? Thanks!

[joaogalli]

Thanks for your response, I don't have a different code from yours (Login Example), I was just trying to do everything in the same Widget.
In LoginPage there is the creation of LoginForm at line 29, instead of this,
I just tried to return the blocListener of LoginForm at line 25.
But it never get called, like it would if they are in separate widgets.

[felangel]

@joaogalli so you just have one StatefulWidget? It should work the same way. Are you able to share a link to your GitHub repository? I can take a look and create a pull request to fix any issue I find.

[joaogalli]

Sorry, I don't have it on a repository, I will try some more and return with what I find.

[felangel]

Sounds good. If it’s easier you can also create a gist and share the link 👍

[felangel]

Closing for now but feel free to comment with additional questions or comments and I'm happy to continue the conversation