Bisq: The change output of 5.41 is below the min dust value of 5,54 ...

Created on 4 Aug 2019  路  6Comments  路  Source: bisq-network/bisq

I am trying to place a offer with BSQ.

The trade fee is only 0.08 what is up with this? I already funded the offer but I can not review and place the trade and this message pops up.

The change output of 5.41 is below the min dust value of 5,54 ...

good first issue usability

Most helpful comment

@rekcus2 It's hard to know which minutia of bitcoin is opaque to people and we can only improve the documentation with more feedback.

The bitcoin network has a minimum limit of 546 satoshis to avoid spam attacks. BSQ being colored bitcoin inherits that. What this translates to is that when using BSQ your change always has to be bigger than 5,46 BSQ. So if the amount you have now will result in a change inferior to 5,46 BSQ, the solution, if you want to use BSQ, is to buy more BSQ.

All 6 comments

The Bitcoin Network doesn't allow you to create outputs bellow 546 satoshis = 5,46 BSQ.

So basically buying that BSQ was totally a waste of time and money for the few trades I do on Bisq. I bought them to save money on trades and now I am sitting on them unable to use them. How about telling people that b4 promoting this stupid token?

@rekcus2 It's hard to know which minutia of bitcoin is opaque to people and we can only improve the documentation with more feedback.

The bitcoin network has a minimum limit of 546 satoshis to avoid spam attacks. BSQ being colored bitcoin inherits that. What this translates to is that when using BSQ your change always has to be bigger than 5,46 BSQ. So if the amount you have now will result in a change inferior to 5,46 BSQ, the solution, if you want to use BSQ, is to buy more BSQ.

can we add a check that prevents that users are getting stuck in this kind of situation?

can we add a check that prevents that users are getting stuck in this kind of situation?

What check do you mean? There is the dust check in place that prevents the publish of a transaction below the dust limit.

Can be closed now, was fixed by https://github.com/bisq-network/bisq/pull/4383

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

cbeams picture cbeams  路  4Comments

ManfredKarrer picture ManfredKarrer  路  5Comments

wenk2018 picture wenk2018  路  3Comments

21isenough picture 21isenough  路  5Comments

julianknutsen picture julianknutsen  路  3Comments