Aws-lambda-dotnet: Support for .NET Core 2.1

[raRaRa]

Hi,

Just curious if .NET Core 2.1 support will become available soon after it has been released, or can we expect it taking a longer time, like what happened with .NET Core 2.0? Are there any significant changes that need to be made to Lambda?

On another note, are there any plans to support .NET Core 2.1 RC1? 🤔

Thanks!

[vellozzi]

We're working hard to make .NET Core 2.1 available in Lambda.
I'm unable to comment on any specific timeline though.
There are no plans to support .NET Core 2.1 RC1.

[raRaRa]

FYI .NET Core 2.1.0 was officially released today. Can't wait to upgrade!

[Kralizek]

@raRaRa was it? I couldn't find it anywhere

[danielabbatt]

All the nuget packages have been updated. Still no announcement by the looks of it.

[zolrath]

Announcement just went up! https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/dotnet/2018/05/30/announcing-net-core-2-1/

[daolavi]

Is .net core 2.1 available in Lambda ? According to this article, it looks like not available yet.

[vellozzi]

It isn't available yet. That blog is the right place to look for the announcement though.

[raRaRa]

How's the progress coming along? 😁

[vellozzi]

Still working on it...

[normj]

Out of curiosity what features in 2.1 are you most excited for when it comes to Lambda?

[raRaRa]

@normj Mostly runtime & networking performance improvements, HttpClientFactory, and Span<T>, Memory<T>, and friends.

[raRaRa]

On another note, are you working on supporting .NET Core 2.1.1 from the start, which has some neat bug fixes, or can we expect 2.1.0 to be supported first?

And thanks for keeping us in the loop, much appreciated. Love the excellent work you guys have done so far. ❤️

[ferugi]

The thing I'm most looking forward to with .NET Core 2.1 is Tired Compilation as I understand it should offer some significant improvements on cold start time.

[federicorinaldi]

Based on the end of life of .NET Core 2 after the release of 2.1 can we get an estimation when this is going to be ready to plan the upgrades?

[jasonwhetton]

Any release date in sight yet? Waiting on this to fix compatibility issues with MongoDB atlas.

[melih154]

Interested in below features.

• EF 2.1
  
  
  
  • Performance
  
  
  • GroupBy
  
  
• .Net Core 2.1
  
  
  
  • ApiController attribute and automatic model validation
  
  

[raRaRa]

Seems like 2.1 was released 22 minutes ago!

FYI

As mentioned in [3], we’re working on the .NET Core 2.1.1 update that came out in late June. We’ll make it available in the AWS Lambda environment as soon as we can.

• https://aws.amazon.com/blogs/developer/aws-lambda-net-core-2-1-support-released/

[normj]

.NET Core 2.1 for Lambda was just released. https://aws.amazon.com/blogs/developer/aws-lambda-net-core-2-1-support-released/

[aaronhudon]

@normj how long until the VSTS AWS Lambda Deploy Function extension is updated to allow runtime 2.1 selection?

[normj]

@aaronhudon We plan on getting VSTS updated next week with the new enum. Unfortunately it got batched up with some other VSTS features we have coming out with the next release. Let me know if that is going to be a problem and I can see what we can work out.

[raRaRa]

Seems like .NET Core 2.1.2 is now out with some security update. Is it going to be difficult/time consuming process for Lambda to support the latest version of .NET Core?

[normj]

@raRaRa We are working on the 2.1.2 but I'm not sure of the timing when it will be in Lambda.

[virzak]

I upgraded the AWS Toolkit to version 1.14.4.0, Microsoft.AspNetCore.App to 2.1.0 and Amazon.Lambda.Tools to 2.2.0

When I Publish to AWS Lambda the dialog shows the correct framework (2.1) and deploys smoothly.

However when I access the API, I get an error and the CloudWatch says:

It was not possible to find any compatible framework version
The specified framework 'Microsoft.AspNetCore.App', version '2.1.0' was not found.
- Check application dependencies and target a framework version installed at:
/
- Alternatively, install the framework version '2.1.0'.
Failed to execute the Lambda function. The dotnet CLI failed to start with the provided deployment package. Please check CloudWatch logs for this Lambda function to get detailed information about this failure.: LambdaException

Am I doing something wrong?

[normj]

In your serverless.template file for the AWS::Serverless::Function resource did you update the Runtime property to dotnetcore2.1. Sorry we should have put that in the blog post.

[virzak]

@normj That was the missing piece. Thanks!

[ferugi]

I've found that for Tiered Compilation to be enabled, it needs to be set as a AWS Function environment variable. E.g. in serverless.template:

"Environment": {
    "Variables": {
        "COMPlus_TieredCompilation" : 1
    }
}

Seems to have a noticable performance improvement on cold start.

[raRaRa]

@ferugi Super interesting, thanks for sharing. Do you know if there are any known side effects of using tiered compilation, e.g. could it actually cause overall worse performance while the startup time becomes faster.

[normj]

@ferugi Any chance you can quantify the performance improvement? I didn't really notice much in my testing but I might not have had enough of a real world scenario.

[ferugi]

Sorry for the slow response. @normj I don't have a good real world example, but a quick test with Lambda and API Gateway gave these results (128mb memory).
@raRaRa I don't know enought to give you a real answer. That said, in the test I ran it did look like there was a bit more variation in response time of subsequent calls when Tiered Compilation was enabled.

[raRaRa]

@normj Any update on support for .NET Core 2.1.2? Thanks!

[vellozzi]

No updates. We're still working on getting it out as soon as we can.

[ayalbelling]

[SOLVED] By deleting and recreating the instance of my app in Beanstalk and then redeploying.

Apparently Dotnet Core 2.1 is supported native on beanstalk according to the link below. But I still get the "Process Failure" message as if it isn't.

https://aws.amazon.com/about-aws/whats-new/2018/06/aws-elastic-beanstalk-supports--net-core-2-1-on-windows-server-p/

[raRaRa]

https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/dotnet/2018/08/02/tiered-compilation-preview-in-net-core-2-1/

[genifycom]

Once you have updated to 2.1.2 then 2.1.0 will no longer allow dynamic changes to cshtml files. I get this error https://github.com/dotnet/core/issues/1728

This has forced us to upgrade to 2.1.2 to get back productivity. Unfortunately we can no longer deploy to Lambda so we are currently stuck.

[binaryPUNCH]

Also quite stuck without the latest patch. Will 2.1.1 / 2.1.2 be ready soon, or should we consider changing our architecture entirely, to self-built docker containers with Fargate/self-hosted Kubernetes?

[vellozzi]

We're working to get 2.1.2 released as soon as possible.
You shouldn't need to change anything.

[virzak]

In the meantime 2.1.3 is out.

Just out of curiosity, what's involved in upgrading to latest .NET major or minor version? Feels like a continuous catch-up cycle.

[vellozzi]

There are a lot of steps behind the scenes to build, test, verify and deploy new runtimes into AWS Lambda.

You're totally right about the catch-up cycle thing. Improving that is one of our top priorities for AWS Lambda .NET Core support.

[PaulDMendoza]

2.1.4 is out now.

[vellozzi]

We're working on that now instead. We'll keep you posted.

[melih154]

Found out that this issue is fixed with .NET Core 2.1.4.

Seems like a good reason to get Lambda Environment upgraded to 2.1.4 soon :) - as it may help on the good use of underlying CPU resources.

Thanks for the work.

[raRaRa]

@melih154 Wow, I wasn't aware of this issue. Is the new socket enabled by default in .NET Core 2.1?

We really need .NET Core 2.1.4 support. 🍕

[raRaRa]

And 2.1.5 is out.
https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/dotnet/2018/10/02/net-core-october-2018-update/

[normj]

Lambda is deployed with 2.1.4 and 2.1.5 is in the development pipeline. The Lambda README has been updated with a new table tracking the current versions. Hope that helps with the visibility.

[raRaRa]

It sure does! Thank you so much.