Antennapod: [Statistics] Make statistics easier to discover

Created on 21 Oct 2020  路  7Comments  路  Source: AntennaPod/AntennaPod

Checklist

  • [x] I have used the search function to see if someone else has already submitted the same feature request.
  • [x] I will only create one feature request per issue.
  • [x] I will describe the problem with as much detail as possible.

App version / source: 2.0.1 / Google Play

Feature description

Right now statistics is only accessible from settings.
It would make it more discoverable if they could be accessed from subscriptions screen :

  • either adding in 3 dots menu access
  • or better as this screen as only one button aside 3 dots menu (as palylist screen, episode screen have 2)

@keunes also proposed in closed issue #4552 to be able to add it to lateral menu so it could have his own entry

good first issue

Most helpful comment

adding an entry in lateral menu

Hmm, that was my idea, too, when I first added the statistics screen back in 2016. Just like the old maintainers back then, I am now convinced that the feature is not used often enough to justify another sidebar menu entry.

Or it fits more in Playback History either as an option or a teaser panel

While I like the general idea of a teaser panel, I think that it could also lead to problems. Users would want a feature to hide the teaser panel. That would then lead to users no longer finding the statistics screen once they removed the panel.

Maybe a toolbar button on the subscriptions screen really is the least obtrusive and most discoverable option that we have.

All 7 comments

To be honest, I am not sure if I like the idea of adding more buttons to the subscriptions screen. Every additional button makes the app a tiny bit harder to process for new users. I think AntennaPod should try to be as beginner friendly as possible.

I agree on the general point, though. The statistics screen is a bit hard to find and actually does not really fit on a settings screen.

If you don't want to add more button then the best option is what @keunes proposed : adding an entry in lateral menu.
I think it's also good proposal.

Or it fits more in Playback History either as an option or a teaser panel

adding an entry in lateral menu

Hmm, that was my idea, too, when I first added the statistics screen back in 2016. Just like the old maintainers back then, I am now convinced that the feature is not used often enough to justify another sidebar menu entry.

Or it fits more in Playback History either as an option or a teaser panel

While I like the general idea of a teaser panel, I think that it could also lead to problems. Users would want a feature to hide the teaser panel. That would then lead to users no longer finding the statistics screen once they removed the panel.

Maybe a toolbar button on the subscriptions screen really is the least obtrusive and most discoverable option that we have.

+1 @ByteHamster

IMHO in the long run I think there will also be a need to think about displaying podcast list in lateral menu.
I think it will make sense to make it disappears because it's not really useful if you have a lot of podcast. Hence request for folders or tags.

I created a topic on the forum to speak more about it. It would be easier to exchange thoughts about UI : https://forum.antennapod.org/t/thoughts-about-ui-keep-it-simple-but-allow-powerful-features/289

I think it will make sense to make it disappears because it's not really useful if you have a lot of podcast

You know you can remove the list via the menu settings? Simply long-press one of the other menu entries to change your selection.

@keunes I know and it is what I did. It was more a comment about keeping this feature or making it not default if it is still is.

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings